institutional fact
A fact whose existence presupposes human institutions; facts like citizenship, money, or marriage that are created and maintained by human societies
As defined in The Logical Structure of Human Civilization (John Searle)
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 10 of 12Search all claims for “institutional fact” →
- Sometimes you can create an institutional fact out of thin air without any physical X term—most money has no physical existence; money in a bank account is purely representational, existing only as magnetic traces on computer disks in the bank's systemsThe Logical Structure of Human Civilization (John Searle)
- There is an interesting asymmetry between how constitutive rules operate in language versus non-linguistic institutional facts: when you make a statement in language, no powers arise beyond the semantic powers of the language itself, but when you create non-linguistic institutional facts, the powers go beyond languageThe Logical Structure of Human Civilization (John Searle)
- Many traditional issues in philosophy and social science are clarified by recognizing that institutional facts are created and maintained through status function declarations, including debates about human rights, which are not properties humans have intrinsically but status functions created by declaration.The Logical Structure of Human Civilization (John Searle)
- An institutional fact presupposes human institutions and is distinct from brute facts—facts like hydrogen atoms having one electron or the earth being 93 million miles from the sun that don't presuppose any institutionsThe Logical Structure of Human Civilization (John Searle)
- Christmas Day is an institutional fact because being on Christmas Day carries deontic powers—obligations to give children presents and rights to time off—whereas the Christian calendar itself is not an institutional fact because merely being such-and-such a date does not carry deontic powers.The Logical Structure of Human Civilization (John Searle)
- Some status functions would suffer if they were codified—cocktail parties, love affairs, and friendship are status functions with deontic powers, but codifying them would make them rigid and less flexibleThe Logical Structure of Human Civilization (John Searle)
- A key difference between humans and other animals like dogs is that humans have the capacity to create institutional facts—facts that presuppose human institutions—whereas other animals do not worry about such mattersThe Logical Structure of Human Civilization (John Searle)
- The second capacity needed to create institutional facts is the human ability to impose functions on objects—to take an object and give it a function through intentional assignment that is observer-relativeThe Logical Structure of Human Civilization (John Searle)
- Sometimes you don't need a rule to create an institutional fact—a bunch of kids can just decide that somebody is going to be captain of the softball team without needing a constitution to appeal toThe Logical Structure of Human Civilization (John Searle)
- To get from brute facts to institutional facts, humans need three basic things: first, the remarkable capacity for collective intentionality—the ability to cooperate with other peopleThe Logical Structure of Human Civilization (John Searle)