indeterminacy
The property of physical systems in which the current state does not uniquely fix a single future; multiple outcomes remain genuinely possible, present at quantum and, Mitchell argues, classical levels.
As defined in Free Will Is Real (with Kevin Mitchell)
Where it comes up · 2
- Free Will Is Real (with Kevin Mitchell)3 claims
- Agency, Attractors, & Observer-Dependent Computation in Biology & Beyond1 claim
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “indeterminacy” →
- When the future is genuinely open and multiple things could happen, the way a system is organized can do causal work by constraining which trajectories are possible at a macroscopic level—just as a computer constrains electron paths via hardware and software without violating physics or micromanaging individual quantum events—because the underlying physics is probabilistic and not causally complete, leaving causal slack for higher-level control.Free Will Is Real (with Kevin Mitchell)
- The free-will debate wrongly assumes determinism is dictated by physics; in fact physics does not say the world is deterministic—there is inherent indeterminacy at the quantum level (well known) and also at the classical level (less well known), so the real challenge is explaining where organismal control comes from, not where freedom comes from.Free Will Is Real (with Kevin Mitchell)
- Sapolsky concedes there is indeterminacy in the universe but argues it cannot ground free will because such indeterminacy only acts on you—you cannot control it or act on it—so it merely introduces randomness rather than agency.Free Will Is Real (with Kevin Mitchell)
- The question of whether there is a zero point on the spectrum of agency/persuadability is genuinely difficult; the minimal requirements for agency are goal-directed behavior (systems that tend toward particular outcomes despite perturbation) and some degree of indeterminacy (behavior not fully determined by immediate local causes), both of which are present in elementary particles through least action principles.Agency, Attractors, & Observer-Dependent Computation in Biology & Beyond