illusionism
The materialist view that consciousness—including selfhood and the sense of control—is an illusion produced by underlying physical processes rather than a genuine causal agent.
As defined in Rational and Religious (with Ross Douthat)
Where it comes up · 3
- Rational and Religious (with Ross Douthat)2 claims
- 322 - Predicting Reality1 claim
- 25 | David Chalmers on Consciousness, the Hard Problem, and Living in a Simulation1 claim
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “illusionism” →
- Clark is an illusionist who denies the hard problem: experience does not float free of behavioral profiles, and once you fully specify a system's actual and counterfactual behavior—how it groups, sorts, classifies, and reports—you have fixed the nature of its experience; there is no further hidden, in-principle-undetectable fact, so the philosophical zombie is not a zombie at all but simply a conscious being.322 - Predicting Reality
- The best materialist account of consciousness reduces to illusionism—the claim that selfhood and control are illusions—but this is self-undermining because if consciousness does nothing, the underlying processes would run the same way without it, so a universe where systems simply ran on their own would be simpler than one with a non-functional conscious observer.Rational and Religious (with Ross Douthat)
- We have access to two categories of experience—mind (direct conscious experience) and matter (filtered through consciousness)—and there are good reasons to think mind is primary rather than derivative of matter, because no materialist account adequately explains how conscious experience arises from physical brain processes.Rational and Religious (with Ross Douthat)
- Illusionism is the recently resurgent view that consciousness is an internal introspective illusion: a strong introspective mechanism makes us think we have special phenomenal properties (qualia) when in fact 'all is dark inside,' as it is for a zombie; the view is hard to believe, but it has the dialectical advantage that it predicts we would find it impossible to believe.25 | David Chalmers on Consciousness, the Hard Problem, and Living in a Simulation