ideal theory
In moral and political philosophy, the approach of defining a perfect society or outcome and moving toward it; debated against incremental, non-ideal approaches.
As defined in AMA | December 2021
Where it comes up · 4
- 182 | Sally Haslanger on Social Construction and Critical Theory2 claims
- AMA | December 20212 claims
- 139 | Elizabeth Anderson on Equality, Work, and Ideology1 claim
- 269 | Sahar Heydari Fard on Complexity, Justice, and Social Dynamics1 claim
Most important claims · 6 of 6Search all claims for “ideal theory” →
- Because human beings are bounded, finite beings — computationally and informationally circumscribed — we lack the time or capacity for perfect reasoning and will always use heuristics rather than pure Bayesianism or utilitarianism; this finitude is genuinely important and has been put to work in psychology (e.g. the free energy principle as a shortcut to Bayesian updating) and in moral/political philosophy debates about ideal theory.AMA | December 2021
- Detached 'ivory tower' reasoning is legitimate and valuable for making distinctions and clarifying means, but it is not the best at helping us think about our ends, because understanding our ends must be grounded in our experience, history, form of life, and environment — so ends-reasoning that is not informed by what people on the ground value can go badly astray.182 | Sally Haslanger on Social Construction and Critical Theory
- Political theory concerns the state and its power to enforce rights, but it leaves most of our lives untouched; social theory concerns how we live collectively in social practices, where ideal theory is ridiculous because you cannot design the perfect society — instead you must analyze existing practices to see who is advantaged and disadvantaged.182 | Sally Haslanger on Social Construction and Critical Theory
- It is more feasible to start from where we are and make things a little better than to define a perfect ideal society and move toward it, because (per Elizabeth Anderson) there may be no such thing as the ideal theory — as society and conditions change, we may learn more and change our minds about what we want society to be — and a similar logic likely applies to everyday personal decisions.AMA | December 2021
- Because the social optimization problem is too complex for any individual or institution to have a bird's-eye view of the landscape, the right approach is non-ideal: rather than identifying and aiming at a perfect society, focus on how to make local improvements—asking about the local derivative is more sensible than asking about the final goal.269 | Sahar Heydari Fard on Complexity, Justice, and Social Dynamics
- Aiming political philosophy at an ideal society is unreliable because we cannot know what the relevant normative categories will be in the future, ideal theory tends to paper over present structural injustices, and moral inquiry may never converge on a fixed ideal—so we should start from current problems and treat our ideals as error-prone, revising them by living through them.139 | Elizabeth Anderson on Equality, Work, and Ideology