homelessness (as propaganda word)
Language that frames street addiction and untreated mental illness problems as housing shortages, linguistically constraining policy responses to housing-first solutions and obscuring other causes
As defined in Michael Shellenberger - Why Progressives Ruin Cities
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 10 of 15Search all claims for “homelessness (as propaganda word)” →
- European cities (Amsterdam, Lisbon, Vienna, Zurich) that banned public camping and open-air drug dealing, while providing methadone or Suboxone replacement therapy and mandatory treatment, successfully reduced chronic street homelessness across different political ideologies—conservative tough-love advocates and liberal harm-reduction supporters both converged on this model.Michael Shellenberger - Why Progressives Ruin Cities
- After World War II, the United States saw gradual increases in tolerance for public drunkenness and street homelessness, but the major turning point was reducing psychiatric hospital populations by 90-95% without providing community infrastructure, leading directly to street homelessness crisis.Michael Shellenberger - Why Progressives Ruin Cities
- The term 'homelessness' functions as propaganda because it linguistically frames the problem as purely housing-related, obscuring the actual root causes of street addiction and untreated mental illness that require mandatory intervention and treatment.Michael Shellenberger - Why Progressives Ruin Cities
- In the 1960s, philosopher Michel Foucault promoted the idea that mental illness is a 'myth' constructed by society, an ideology still held by organizations like the ACLU, which has used this to oppose involuntary psychiatric treatment and enable street homelessness through non-intervention.Michael Shellenberger - Why Progressives Ruin Cities
- San Francisco spends about 10 times more per homeless person than the national average, yet homelessness has worsened, demonstrating that increased spending without addressing root causes of mental illness and addiction does not solve the problem.Michael Shellenberger - Why Progressives Ruin Cities
- Street addiction and chronic homelessness populations differ dramatically in difficulty: people homeless for only days/weeks respond well to housing and services, while people homeless 2+ decades with untreated schizophrenia and methamphetamine addiction are the hardest to serve and most likely to be rejected by non-profit service providers.Michael Shellenberger - Why Progressives Ruin Cities
- The romantic ideal of street homelessness (hobos, riding the rails, anarchist IWW movement in early San Francisco) has been absorbed into modern street culture, making street life seem like 'Pleasure Island' (from Pinocchio) to young addicts—a trap disguised as freedom.Michael Shellenberger - Why Progressives Ruin Cities
- If the problem of non-solved homelessness/drug crisis persists at this scale, somebody must be profiting from it or it provides psychological benefit (identity as caregiver); the existence of a problem at this magnitude suggests systematic under-solving is economically or psychologically rational for some stakeholders.Michael Shellenberger - Why Progressives Ruin Cities
- Republicans have failed to prosecute the homelessness issue effectively against Democrats despite Democratic control of California because voters don't trust Republicans care about vulnerable people; Republicans need to propose robust care solutions (like calcite) to win trust.Michael Shellenberger - Why Progressives Ruin Cities
- The key insight from talking to Renee (a Dutch drug policy expert) was that homelessness requires 'carrots and sticks'—incentives and consequences throughout the entire journey, not just carrots (handouts), and that San Francisco provides only carrots without sticks.Michael Shellenberger - Why Progressives Ruin Cities