holdout
A property owner who refuses to sell or convert their rights, capturing benefits from a development while obstructing a collective decision.
As defined in Paul Romer on Urban Growth
Where it comes up · 3
- Richard Epstein on Classical Liberalism, Libertarianism, and Lochner2 claims
- Paul Romer on Urban Growth1 claim
- Richard Epstein on Property Rights and Drug Patents 2/19/20071 claim
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “holdout” →
- Common-pool resources require some regulation to prevent over-fishing, over-hunting, and over-extraction; with oil and gas in the 1890s, once more than about five separate owners share a field, voluntary bargaining breaks down and output is wrecked, so unitization or pooling imposed by the state (and demanded by industry) can yield up to a five-fold increase in output for a roughly 2% increase in cost.Richard Epstein on Classical Liberalism, Libertarianism, and Lochner
- Bilateral and multilateral employment contracts can be handled by market institutions backed by public force, but many production arrangements—building roads, bankruptcy proceedings, banking, railroad interchanges—require coordination that voluntary means cannot achieve because of holdout problems and monopoly, so the state may need to mandate, for example, interchange between parties on fair terms, since pure freedom of contract does not always reach the right result.Richard Epstein on Classical Liberalism, Libertarianism, and Lochner
- Fragmented land ownership over generations creates unusable plots and disputes, so primogeniture was adopted to keep parcels whole; likewise, many small rights that must combine are hard to assemble, yet cartel-like price fixing among competing viable firms must be avoided.Richard Epstein on Property Rights and Drug Patents 2/19/2007
- When large numbers of people each hold a veto right through their property rights, it is almost impossible to make a collective redevelopment decision; switching people from individual property rights to shares in a corporate entity (requiring only a supermajority) can sometimes succeed, but holdouts who refuse to convert can still capture benefits and slow the whole process.Paul Romer on Urban Growth