herd immunity
The point at which enough of a population is immune that disease spread slows; Taleb argues reduced connectivity, not herd immunity, is what makes pandemics implode.
As defined in et_747
Where it comes up · 16
- Paul Romer on the COVID-19 Pandemic2 claims
- Vinay Prasad on the Pandemic2 claims
- The Power of Nuance: Lessons for Public Health (with Emily Oster)2 claims
- 325 - A Few Thoughts About Rfk Jr2 claims
- 335 - A Postmortem On My Response To Covid2 claims
- 222 - A Pandemic Of Incompetence2 claims
- Ask Me Anything 172 claims
- Daniel Carpenter1 claim
and 8 more
Most important claims · 10 of 23Search all claims for “herd immunity” →
- Covid warranted deferring to whatever expert consensus existed at any moment because it was a public-health emergency with tremendous uncertainty, collective-action problems, a ticking clock, and a moving target—unlike static topics such as jihadism or crime/police-violence data, where 'doing your own research' was responsible because the facts were accessible and unchanging.335 - A Postmortem On My Response To Covid
- SARS-CoV-2 has an intrinsic transmissibility (R-naught) of about 2.5 to 3.5, far higher than seasonal flu (0.9 to 1.6) but lower than measles (around 18), and the more transmissible a disease the higher the fraction of the population that must acquire immunity or be vaccinated for herd immunity; the effective reproduction number (R-sub-e) is what physical distancing manipulates to push transmission below one.222 - A Pandemic Of Incompetence
- People treat getting vaccinated as an act of commission carrying greater ethical concern than the act of omission of not getting vaccinated, but in this case omission makes one a free rider on herd immunity and a potential breeding ground for new variants, so it is appropriate to judge people for it.Ask Me Anything 17
- Vaccines must be given on the schedules set by the CDC, the American Academy of Pediatrics, and family practitioners because most vaccines don't work after only the first or second shot—booster shots are required—so when children follow alternative or made-up schedules and large populations go unvaccinated or undervaccinated, previously near-eradicated illnesses come back.129 - An Insider S View Of Medicine
- Rushing vaccines out in summer or fall 2020—when expressed willingness to be vaccinated had dropped 10-15 percentage points, concentrated among the young who are most needed for herd immunity—would have produced a social catastrophe of tens of millions refusing the vaccine, costing thousands of lives, because vaccines with positive externalities are only as valuable as the share of the population that actually takes them.Daniel Carpenter
- The original civic-responsibility argument for vaccination—that taking it would prevent transmission, achieve herd immunity, and protect the vulnerable—lost its ethical basis once it became clear vaccines weren't preventing infection and transmission, since people should then be free to make a medical choice affecting only themselves.335 - A Postmortem On My Response To Covid
- Sweden's no-lockdown approach initially looked bad—death rates higher than Norway and Denmark—and that judgment hinged on whether a vaccine was imminent; but once it became clear no vaccine was coming soon, Sweden saw less of a second wave, and it remains unclear how much is herd immunity, learned behaviors, or testing differences, illustrating that evaluating lockdown policy requires a long time horizon.Emily Oster on the Pandemic
- With the far more transmissible Delta variant, the expected herd-immunity dynamic has been inverted: instead of a vaccinated majority protecting an unvaccinated minority by denying the virus hosts, the substantial unvaccinated minority is now driving infections that reach into the vaccinated population.256 - A Contagion Of Bad Ideas
- A Yale study suggests the vaccines saved close to a million lives as of late summer 2020, but the full benefit is larger because vaccines stabilized the healthcare system—preventing it from being overwhelmed, which let other illnesses be treated—and prevented long COVID, a debilitating condition of foggy brain, lethargy, and pain lasting over a year.Gregory Zuckerman on the Crazy Race to Create the COVID Vaccine
- The Great Barrington Declaration has been mischaracterized as a 'herd immunity' or 'let-it-rip' strategy, which is a propaganda term reflecting a refusal to engage with the actual ideas, when in fact the proposal is to weigh costs and benefits carefully and protect the vulnerable, not to let the disease spread.Jay Bhattacharya on the Pandemic