hard problem
David Chalmers' term for the problem of why there is subjective experience at all—why it is 'like something' to be conscious—contrasted with the 'easy problems' of cognitive function.
As defined in 78 | Daniel Dennett on Minds, Patterns, and the Scientific Image
Where it comes up · 6
- 404 - What If Consciousness Is Fundamental6 claims
- 264 - Consciousness And Self Rebroadcast2 claims
- 25 | David Chalmers on Consciousness, the Hard Problem, and Living in a Simulation2 claims
- What Venus Flytraps, ChatGPT, and LSD reveal about consciousness | Michael Pollan1 claim
- 317 - What Do We Know About Our Minds1 claim
- 78 | Daniel Dennett on Minds, Patterns, and the Scientific Image1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 13Search all claims for “hard problem” →
- The felt experience of seeing yellow does not exist in the world — only light wavelengths do; the brain generates the experience of yellow, and since cameras, computers, and plants also process light wavelengths without our assuming they have experience, it is mysterious why brains should produce a felt experience at all.404 - What If Consciousness Is Fundamental
- Chalmers's hard problem—why is it like anything at all to be me, the problem of qualia—is precisely the trap you fall into if you stop and refuse to answer the hard question 'and then what happens?'; failing to ask it leaves you with a gob-smacking, mind-deadening mystery, and qualia are a term of art born of bad theorizing that has misguided decades of work and seduced many scientists.78 | Daniel Dennett on Minds, Patterns, and the Scientific Image
- Intelligence, life, and nearly everything else science explains can be fully defined by their extrinsic properties — what they do to other things and their input-output characteristics — so once that behavior is explained nothing is left out, except consciousness, which is intrinsically defined.404 - What If Consciousness Is Fundamental
- The analogy between explaining life and explaining consciousness is false because everything about life except conscious experience can be defined in terms of extrinsic functional relationships among material parts, whereas consciousness adds the inexplicable fact that for some processes there is something it is like to be them, leaving a brute-fact residue that other scientific explanations do not.264 - Consciousness And Self Rebroadcast
- Philosophical zombie arguments are weak because the more you know about how a system works (the easy problem), the harder it becomes to genuinely conceive of a functionally identical system with no experience, just as learning aerodynamics makes it harder to conceive of a 747 flying backwards; if zombies cannot truly be imagined, the hard problem loses force.264 - Consciousness And Self Rebroadcast
- Consciousness is unique among everything science studies because it can never be directly observed from the outside; the only evidence for its existence is intrinsic, on the inside, so no external behavior can announce that there is something it is like to be a system.404 - What If Consciousness Is Fundamental
- Because consciousness leaves no external signature, we will soon build robots and AI systems that seem conscious to us, but we will have no way of knowing whether they are actually conscious unless we understand how or whether consciousness arises from information processing.404 - What If Consciousness Is Fundamental
- All theories of consciousness eventually run up against the 'hard problem'—the question of how a conscious subject arises from physical processes, how that subjective quality emerges from matter—and none of the theories Pollan examined successfully answer this.What Venus Flytraps, ChatGPT, and LSD reveal about consciousness | Michael Pollan
- The 'strong assumption' — that consciousness arises out of complex processing in brains and central nervous systems — is an assumption science made because we are conscious creatures who can only gather evidence by communicating with systems similar to ourselves, but we actually have no good reason to begin with it.404 - What If Consciousness Is Fundamental
- What began as the question of whether consciousness goes deeper in nature than the sciences assumed led to the conclusion that if it goes deeper at all, it must go all the way down, making the real question whether consciousness is fundamental.404 - What If Consciousness Is Fundamental