group selection
The contested idea in evolutionary biology that natural selection can act at the level of groups rather than only individuals or genes.
As defined in cwt_michael-nielsen
Other definitions
The contested evolutionary idea that natural selection can act on groups, favoring traits beneficial to the group even at a cost to the individual; also called multi-level selection.
31 - Evolving Minds
Where it comes up · 21
- 185 | Arvid Ågren on the Gene's-Eye View of Evolution3 claims
- Matt Ridley on the Evolution of Everything2 claims
- Reclaiming Tribalism (with Michael Morris)2 claims
- 106 | Stuart Bartlett on What "Life" Means2 claims
- 247 | Samuel Bowles on Economics, Cooperation, and Inequality2 claims
- 281 | Samir Okasha on the Philosophy of Agency and Evolution2 claims
- Steven Pinker1 claim
- Tyler Cowen - The Great Reset1 claim
and 13 more
Most important claims · 10 of 28Search all claims for “group selection” →
- Group selection has meant two different things historically: 'naive group selection' where individuals sacrifice for the good of the species and group fitness is measured by groups producing new groups; versus modern group selection where fitness is measured by individuals producing individuals but accounting for a group property that is not meaningfully reducible to individual-level properties.185 | Arvid Ågren on the Gene's-Eye View of Evolution
- Contrary to the belief that morality requires God, selfish genes evolved to build genuinely unselfish people because unselfishness was a brilliant survival strategy that could spread across a species, making humans the cooperating species whose trust mechanisms underlie civilization itself.349 - Generosity Cynicism And The Future Of Doing Good
- The hero instinct is our drive to be not merely normal but normative—an exemplary, contributing group member who earns esteem—and it pairs with prestige learning, whereby we identify who has status (by tracking whom others attend to) and emulate them, which spreads adaptive innovations through a group.Reclaiming Tribalism (with Michael Morris)
- While whole societies do live and die at the expense of other societies, this is a smaller and rarer effect than the competition between individuals, businesses, families, and ideas within a society; Hayek's mistake was overemphasizing group selection because he came of age when biologists wrongly stressed species competing against species rather than individuals within a species.Matt Ridley on the Evolution of Everything
- Describing how evolution gave apes like us our moral attitudes is a distinct project from deciding how we should live now; we are continually flying the perch evolution prepared for us through technology, institutions, and new moral norms that have nothing to do with ancient selection pressures.67 - Meaning And Chaos
- Group selection has been wrongly reduced to groups competing with one another; properly understood, saying a trait is selected does not require competition (escaping a fox enhances fitness without fighting a conspecific), so group selection means only that the evolutionary dynamic favors the evolution of groups with certain social interactions, regardless of intergroup competition.164 | Herbert Gintis on Game Theory, Evolution, and Social Rationality
- Religion cannot be merely a mind virus because it is too expensive to bear; persistent costly traits generally must be delivering some fitness benefit, since otherwise they would be easily excised—so Dawkins, in treating religion as a tax on fitness and rejecting group-level advantage, has it wrong, and the better account involves inclusive fitness and multi-level selection in an interplay between gene and meme.41 - Faith In Reason
- Dual inheritance theory holds that genetic and cultural evolution coevolve in a spiral: when cultural evolution reaches a certain point it creates new selection pressures on genetic evolution, which then changes and enables new levels of cultural evolution, and cultural evolution operates largely through group selection that helps groups outcompete other groups.Reclaiming Tribalism (with Michael Morris)
- Group selection works as an individual-based evolutionary process: it requires only that members of a group be more genetically related to each other than to a random member of the population, so group selection is essentially kin selection extended to larger, more genetically distant groups.247 | Samuel Bowles on Economics, Cooperation, and Inequality
- Although within any group altruists are disadvantaged because they bear fitness costs, a group composed mostly of altruists outcompetes groups without them; if past human groups were genetically different enough and competed for resources (e.g., during environmental crises or conflict), group selection could overcome within-group erosion of altruism, making humans possibly uniquely capable of evolving genetic altruism.247 | Samuel Bowles on Economics, Cooperation, and Inequality