greater good rationalization problem
The problem that a moral person may justify committing a negative moral act because it enables a larger positive good, which undermines trust.
As defined in David Rose on the Moral Foundations of Economic Behavior
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 3 of 3Search all claims for “greater good rationalization problem” →
- Opening the door to greater-good justification starts a slippery slope of self-deception, where a person rationalizes acts that are really for their own benefit by telling themselves it was for someone else (e.g., 'for my nephew'); this Smithian danger means greater-good rationalization easily becomes self-serving rationalization.David Rose on the Moral Foundations of Economic Behavior
- Even a person with principled moral restraint may feel compelled to commit a negative moral act if doing so enables a larger positive moral good (the greater good rationalization problem); this destroys trust because you cannot trust someone who might cheat you to help a third party they value more, so genuine trust requires the partner to not even think in those utilitarian terms.David Rose on the Moral Foundations of Economic Behavior
- The risky lending behavior during the financial crisis reflected the breakdown of principled moral restraint: people knew the loans were wrong but rationalized them because the harm was diffuse ('nobody's dying') and they told themselves they were doing good by putting a person in a house, with the con working only as long as house prices kept rising.David Rose on the Moral Foundations of Economic Behavior