good explanation
In Deutsch's epistemology, an explanation that is hard to vary while still accounting for what it purports to explain, and which cannot be appropriated by competing arbitrary claims
As defined in 52 - Finding Our Way In The Cosmos
Where it comes up · 3
- David Deutsch: Knowledge Creation and The Human Race, Part 18 claims
- Gustav Söderström - How Spotify Thinks - [Invest Like the Best, EP.424]4 claims
- 52 - Finding Our Way In The Cosmos1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 13Search all claims for “good explanation” →
- Pattern recognition only iterates along an existing path, so transformative leaps like geocentric to heliocentric or quantum physics require explanation, which can produce entirely unintuitive conclusions that patterns cannot reach.Gustav Söderström - How Spotify Thinks - [Invest Like the Best, EP.424]
- If we genuinely know that something benefits people and the theory rests on a good explanation, we should be able to persuade them to accept it rather than coerce them; if a benefit cannot be brought within reach of someone's consent, that itself counts against imposing it, because the universe is indifferent rather than malevolent and good explanations generally find routes that respect the person's own preferences.52 - Finding Our Way In The Cosmos
- A good explanation must be hard to vary, meaning that swapping any parameter should break its predictive power; conspiracy theories are easy to vary because the actor can be swapped for another with the same result, which marks them as likely untrue.Gustav Söderström - How Spotify Thinks - [Invest Like the Best, EP.424]
- Modern AI systems like GPT-3, Stable Diffusion, and DALL-E are sophisticated pattern-matching systems, not genuinely creative or intelligent, because they cannot form good explanations of underlying phenomena or create new knowledge.David Deutsch: Knowledge Creation and The Human Race, Part 1
- Theories that immunize themselves against criticism (like 'God works in mysterious ways' or 'it's an incomprehensible simulation') cannot be rejected and fail to be good explanations because they eliminate the possibility of critical evaluation.David Deutsch: Knowledge Creation and The Human Race, Part 1
- Once a good explanation has been developed and validated, it becomes difficult to switch back to easy, simpler explanations even if we wanted to, because the good explanation accounts for multiple phenomena that the easy explanation cannot.David Deutsch: Knowledge Creation and The Human Race, Part 1
- Narrow and risky predictions are components of good explanations because they represent cases where the explanation is sticking its neck out and testing something unexpected; the explanation would lose credibility if these precise predictions failed.David Deutsch: Knowledge Creation and The Human Race, Part 1
- Gustav argues that product intuition called 'magic' is actually pattern recognition from seniority that the person simply cannot explain; a good theory converts that intuition into knowledge the whole company can use.Gustav Söderström - How Spotify Thinks - [Invest Like the Best, EP.424]
- Explanations with reach (explaining multiple domains or phenomena beyond their original domain) are of a different order of goodness than narrow explanations, and are rare; most good explanations don't have much reach, and when they do, this makes them particularly valuableDavid Deutsch: Knowledge Creation and The Human Race, Part 1
- A good explanation is one that meets all criticisms raised against it at present and has no viable rivals with any merit; all explanations are subject to improvement and our conception of what constitutes a good explanation keeps changing.David Deutsch: Knowledge Creation and The Human Race, Part 1