germline editing
Gene editing of eggs, sperm, or embryos that is heritable and passed to future generations.
As defined in 112 | Fyodor Urnov on Gene Editing, CRISPR, and Human Engineering
Where it comes up · 3
- 112 | Fyodor Urnov on Gene Editing, CRISPR, and Human Engineering2 claims
- What You Can Learn From History's Greatest Innovators | Walter Isaacson | The Knowledge Project 1211 claim
- A billion years of evolution in a single afternoon — George Church1 claim
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “germline editing” →
- Germline editing—genetic engineering that passes to future generations—should never be allowed under any circumstances: there is no unmet medical need since the burden of genetic disease can be addressed by safe, ethical somatic means, and the only remaining motive is human enhancement, which is unjustifiable because we have no mechanical way to verify enhancement outcomes that take decades to manifest.112 | Fyodor Urnov on Gene Editing, CRISPR, and Human Engineering
- Jiankui He committed two crimes: he irreversibly stained the field of disease-focused genetic engineering with the imprint of designer babies, and—more deeply—he demonstrated to the world's rogues that human embryo editing can actually be done.112 | Fyodor Urnov on Gene Editing, CRISPR, and Human Engineering
- Voluntary moratoria and whistleblower systems have proven insufficient for biosecurity governance, as demonstrated by the He Jiankui germline editing case where moratoria lasted only 5 years before defection, and despite this being 'quite impressive,' all it takes is one defector to cause catastrophe, so surveillance mechanisms with known consequences must replace reliance on ethics aloneA billion years of evolution in a single afternoon — George Church
- David Sanchez, a 17-year-old with sickle cell disease, initially resisted germline editing to prevent sickle cell in his children because he believed the disease forged his character and gave him empathy—but later changed his view, recognizing he didn't want his children to suffer the pain.What You Can Learn From History's Greatest Innovators | Walter Isaacson | The Knowledge Project 121