general equilibrium effects
The economy-wide or spillover consequences of an intervention beyond its direct recipients — e.g., what happens to a whole local economy when it receives a large influx of cash or chickens.
As defined in Chris Blattman on Chickens, Cash, and Development Economics
Other definitions
The broader, economy-wide impacts of an intervention that arise because everyone is connected through markets and networks, beyond the direct effect on the treated individual.
Michael Faye and Paul Niehaus on GiveDirectly
Where it comes up · 2
- Chris Blattman on Chickens, Cash, and Development Economics2 claims
- Michael Faye and Paul Niehaus on GiveDirectly2 claims
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “general equilibrium effects” →
- Randomized experiments require the assumption that treating one person doesn't affect others so that untreated people serve as a control, but all economic models recognize that everyone is connected through markets and networks; this creates a deep tension because experiments miss the broader General Equilibrium effects, which is especially important for cash since every dollar given is spent somewhere, having a one-for-one accounting impact on others.Michael Faye and Paul Niehaus on GiveDirectly
- Rather than launching a single highly specific large program over 5 years and inevitably redesigning it midway after wasting money, governments and aid agencies should first try 5 or 10 things on a small scale, observe which succeed, ideally study them rigorously, and then scale the most successful — introducing the trial-and-error discipline that randomized testing alone has failed to bring to aid.Chris Blattman on Chickens, Cash, and Development Economics
- In the 2014 village-level study, cash inflows peaked at about 17% of local GDP, and by tracing revenue at local businesses and upward pressure on wages, the researchers estimated a fiscal multiplier of around 2.4 — meaning every dollar injected into the local economy raised output by about two and a half dollars.Michael Faye and Paul Niehaus on GiveDirectly
- Because rich and poor countries already spend on the order of $10 to $100 billion a year giving the poorest people stuff, spending roughly $15 million on a large multi-country experiment comparing interventions like cash and chickens could let aid be twice as effective by killing bad ideas and replacing them with less-bad ones on the margin.Chris Blattman on Chickens, Cash, and Development Economics