gene's-eye view
An approach to evolution treating genes (replicators stably inherited across generations) as the beneficiaries of adaptation, rather than organisms
As defined in 185 | Arvid Ågren on the Gene's-Eye View of Evolution
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 6 of 6Search all claims for “gene's-eye view” →
- George Williams' 1966 book Adaptation and Natural Selection laid out most of the arguments of the gene's-eye view a decade before Dawkins' The Selfish Gene and was profoundly influential among biologists, but because it was aimed at peers it lacked the broad reach that Dawkins' more explicit and forceful popular treatment achieved.185 | Arvid Ågren on the Gene's-Eye View of Evolution
- The gene's-eye view holds that since adaptation must be 'for the good of' something with evolutionary longevity, and genes are passed on intact across generations while organisms (unique combinations of genotype and environment) and groups lack that longevity, the gene is the ultimate beneficiary of any adaptation.185 | Arvid Ågren on the Gene's-Eye View of Evolution
- The gene's-eye view's anthropomorphism is purely 'as if': no one believes genes have attitudes or psychological motivations, but given the mathematical description of population genetics and inclusive fitness, it is as if genes behave selfishly—and even Dawkins drew criticism because his use of 'selfish' slides between meanings (all genes are selfish versus organisms behaving selfishly rather than altruistically).185 | Arvid Ågren on the Gene's-Eye View of Evolution
- The gene's-eye view defines a gene in the old-fashioned, material-agnostic way as any part of a chromosome that is stably inherited across a generation, which means a 'gene' can be of almost arbitrary length, from a tiny fragment to the entire non-recombining portion of the Y chromosome.185 | Arvid Ågren on the Gene's-Eye View of Evolution
- In the gene's-eye view, 'the gene' refers not to a single stretch of DNA in one individual but to the gene type present in all its copies across a population, and it is this type that is conceived as trying to maximize its own representation in the next generation.185 | Arvid Ågren on the Gene's-Eye View of Evolution
- Although the gene's-eye view and inclusive fitness are usually treated as essentially equivalent, there is an underappreciated tension between them: constructing inclusive fitness as an individual-organism property requires assuming the organism has a unity of purpose, an assumption that breaks down in cases of genomic conflict where genes work for their own transmission at the expense of the organism.185 | Arvid Ågren on the Gene's-Eye View of Evolution