gauge symmetry
A local symmetry where physical laws are invariant under transformations that can vary from point to point in spacetime; gauge symmetries underlie the fundamental forces.
As defined in ms_ama_november_2024
Where it comes up · 7
- 321 | David Tong on Open Questions in Quantum Field Theory3 claims
- 275 | Solo: Quantum Fields, Particles, Forces, and Symmetries2 claims
- AMA | November 20212 claims
- 320 | Solo: Complexity and the Universe1 claim
- AMA | April 20241 claim
- AMA | November 20221 claim
- AMA | October 20231 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 11Search all claims for “gauge symmetry” →
- Scientific thinking is fallibilistic and ultimately empirical, but theoretical insight alone—without any new experiment—can dramatically boost or squelch credence in a theory, as demonstrated when 't Hooft proved spontaneously broken gauge theories are renormalizable in the early 1970s, causing interest in Weinberg's previously ignored 1967 electroweak model to surge from near-zero to becoming the most-cited particle physics paper.AMA | November 2021
- All current laws of physics—Maxwell's electromagnetism, Einstein's general relativity, quantum mechanics—are built on objects that cannot be measured even in principle (overall voltage, the metric's coordinate values, the wave function's overall phase); this is gauge symmetry, which is better called gauge redundancy, and physicists do not understand why the laws of physics require introducing these unphysical objects.321 | David Tong on Open Questions in Quantum Field Theory
- The anthropic need for a massless spin-1 boson is distinct from and does not answer the question of why our description of that boson requires introducing unphysical gauge redundancy; the gauge field A-mu has components (like A0, the voltage) that are not physical yet are necessary to describe electromagnetism, and that necessity remains unexplained.321 | David Tong on Open Questions in Quantum Field Theory
- When a gauge symmetry is 'spontaneously broken,' it is not actually broken at all, because a gauge symmetry is merely a redundancy of description (like a coordinate choice); the Higgs field acquiring a nonzero vacuum value hides the symmetry rather than destroying it, and this hiddenness is what allows the W and Z bosons to acquire mass despite gauge invariance naively forbidding it.AMA | November 2021
- At high energies the electromagnetic, weak, and strong forces are described by a unified gauge symmetry, but this does not mean their separate fields merge into one field; rather, the symmetry that relates the distinct fields becomes manifest and unbroken, so the fields remain multiple but are related by a larger symmetry group that is spontaneously broken at low energies.AMA | October 2023
- Magnetic monopoles—a north pole without a south pole, forbidden by one of Maxwell's equations—are expected to exist somewhere in the universe because they arise as solitons in grand unified theories; they appear to be excluded by gauge symmetry (which is crucial), but Dirac found a loophole in the 1930s, so monopoles sit just on the cusp of being disallowed yet sneak through as permitted by the laws of physics.321 | David Tong on Open Questions in Quantum Field Theory
- One can construct a tongue-in-cheek anthropic argument that gauge symmetry must exist: intelligent observers are complex information-processing systems that can only form by dissipating energy, which requires low-mass particles that nonetheless interact strongly enough to carry energy away; the only such particles are gauge bosons (like photons), whose masslessness is permitted by gauge symmetry, so the existence of observers presupposes gauge symmetry.320 | Solo: Complexity and the Universe
- A gauge symmetry directly implies that the force-carrying particles arising from the gauge field must be massless, because mass is a particular kind of potential energy and there is no way to give the field that potential energy while respecting the symmetry; this beautifully accounts for the massless photon and graviton.275 | Solo: Quantum Fields, Particles, Forces, and Symmetries
- If you demand a local (gauge) symmetry—being able to redefine what red, green, blue mean independently at every point in space—you must introduce a new connection field (the gauge field) to keep track of how the axes change from point to point; that connection field is precisely the force field (electromagnetic, gravitational, nuclear), and its existence and interactions with other fields are entirely determined by the demand for the symmetry.275 | Solo: Quantum Fields, Particles, Forces, and Symmetries
- Physical symmetries, especially gauge symmetries, can be understood as redundancies in our description—much like redundant data in a file that permits compression—suggesting that a more compact, symmetry-free representation of the physics might exist; gauge symmetry in particular is often regarded by physicists as a descriptive redundancy rather than a fundamental physical feature.AMA | April 2024