gain-of-function research
Research that deliberately enhances a pathogen's capabilities (e.g., transmissibility), cited as an example of poorly controlled downstream risk.
As defined in Erik Hoel on the Threat to Humanity from AI
Other definitions
Research that deliberately enhances a pathogen's transmissibility or lethality to study it, raising biosafety and dual-use concerns
187 | Andrew Leigh on the Politics of Looming Disasters
Where it comes up · 7
- 187 | Andrew Leigh on the Politics of Looming Disasters3 claims
- 307 - Twitter Elon Free Speech2 claims
- 208 - Existential Risk2 claims
- Your Mind Has Been Lying to You - Sam Harris (4K)1 claim
- Erik Hoel on the Threat to Humanity from AI1 claim
- Misinformation and the Three Languages of Politics (with Arnold Kling)1 claim
- Peter Thiel on 'Anti-Anti-Anti-Anti Classical Liberalism' | Oxford Union1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 11Search all claims for “gain-of-function research” →
- Twitter genuinely malfunctioned by throttling tweets from doctors like Jay Bhattacharya who were skeptical of COVID policies, but this happened because tweets were first flagged by misinformation-detection bots amid a deluge of real misinformation and then reviewed by outsourced reviewers unqualified to judge medical veracity, during a period when almost no one was qualified because COVID was a moving target.307 - Twitter Elon Free Speech
- Suppression of stories like the COVID lab-leak hypothesis can stem from three motives: a possibly good motive of tamping down what seems a conspiracy theory, a self-interested motive of protecting gain-of-function research funding, and—most powerfully—a status motive whereby scientists protect their collective prestige; the status motive especially explains the refusal to admit mistakes, even though refusing actually lowers status more.Misinformation and the Three Languages of Politics (with Arnold Kling)
- Given that COVID may well have been a lab leak and that biological lab leaks have occurred before, we should take seriously that humanity is generally bad at controlling the downstream effects of its increased understanding—of biology via gain-of-function research, and even more so of our ability to create hyper-intelligent beings whose consequences are hard to foresee.Erik Hoel on the Threat to Humanity from AI
- The COVID lab-leak hypothesis was always plausible and should never have been considered a woke shibboleth to dismiss as racist, as some institutions treated it; Rand Paul was correct in his confrontational exchange with Fauci about gain-of-function research, and Fauci appears to have been defending himself rather than engaging honestly.Your Mind Has Been Lying to You - Sam Harris (4K)
- Natural pandemics rarely combine extreme contagiousness with extreme deadliness because a virus has an evolutionary interest in not killing its host too fast, but bio-engineered pathogens face no such constraint and could be designed to lurk asymptomatically before turning highly fatal, making them potentially far more dangerous than any naturally occurring disease.187 | Andrew Leigh on the Politics of Looming Disasters
- Publishing gain-of-function research that shows how to make dangerous pathogens worse is risky, illustrated by University of Alberta researchers who synthesized a smallpox cousin (horsepox) from mail-ordered DNA for about $100,000 in six months; when Science declined to publish on Dual Use Research of Concern grounds, the team simply published in another journal, showing the need for standards covering both journals and researchers.187 | Andrew Leigh on the Politics of Looming Disasters
- Even the highest-biosecurity (BSL-4) labs have failed at containment: the 2007 UK foot-and-mouth outbreak was traced to a leak from a high-security bio lab (with a maximum fine of only £5,000 despite the 2001 outbreak causing £8 billion in damage), the last smallpox case was a UK lab escape, and SARS escaped a Beijing lab—demonstrating that well-intentioned research routinely fails containment.208 - Existential Risk
- Gain-of-function research, in which well-meaning scientists make pathogens like H5N1 bird flu more transmissible or lethal, can create something worse than anything nature would produce, and crucially escapes the comforting fossil-record argument since it raises risk above the historical baseline.208 - Existential Risk
- The mRNA vaccine, a potential scientific breakthrough, cannot be celebrated in public forums because it is mentally adjacent to the Wuhan lab's gain-of-function research, and this association contaminates the technology with fears of bioweapons.Peter Thiel on 'Anti-Anti-Anti-Anti Classical Liberalism' | Oxford Union
- The Biological Weapons Convention has a monitoring budget smaller than that of a typical McDonald's restaurant, leaving the world dangerously under-resourced to prevent terrorists from acquiring the materials to engineer a pandemic—what the Nixon administration called a 'poor man's atomic bomb.'187 | Andrew Leigh on the Politics of Looming Disasters