firewall paradox
A sharpened version of the black hole information paradox arguing that preserving quantum information forces a high-energy 'firewall' of structure at the horizon, which contradicts general relativity's prediction that an infalling observer should notice nothing special crossing the horizon.
As defined in 218 | Raphael Bousso on Black Holes and the Holographic Universe
Where it comes up · 3
- 218 | Raphael Bousso on Black Holes and the Holographic Universe4 claims
- 99 | Scott Aaronson on Complexity, Computation, and Quantum Gravity2 claims
- Holiday Message | Hits and Misses2 claims
Most important claims · 8 of 8Search all claims for “firewall paradox” →
- The AMPS firewall paradox arises because an outgoing late Hawking photon must be entangled with an early outgoing photon (to conserve information) yet also maximally entangled with an infalling photon (for the event horizon to look like empty space), but the monogamy of entanglement forbids a maximally-entangled system from also being entangled with a third — forcing the conclusion that the horizon is not empty space but a high-energy firewall.Holiday Message | Hits and Misses
- Whether two subsystems are entangled can have different answers depending on whether you ask about the global wave function or about a single branch; the early-late photon entanglement is a global-wave-function (information-conservation) question while horizon smoothness is a branch-level (measurement-outcome) question, so the two required entanglements are not in conflict, and there may be enough branches of the black hole wave function that no individual branch — and hence no infalling observer — encounters a firewall.Holiday Message | Hits and Misses
- Harlow and Hayden gave evidence that the quantum computation required to detect the relevant correlations in Hawking radiation — needed to provoke the firewall — would take a number of steps exponential in the number of qubits of the black hole, meaning roughly 2-to-the-(10-to-the-67) years, so you could not make a dent in the computation before the black hole itself evaporated, plausibly dissolving the paradox.99 | Scott Aaronson on Complexity, Computation, and Quantum Gravity
- The 2012 AMPS firewall paradox showed that a small set of seemingly-true postulates — including that an infalling observer notices nothing special crossing the event horizon and that black holes rapidly scramble information — implies a contradiction: an observer who measures subtle correlations in Hawking radiation after a black hole is more than 50% evaporated and then jumps in would either see quantum mechanics break down or hit a wall of ultra-high-energy photons (a firewall) at the horizon.99 | Scott Aaronson on Complexity, Computation, and Quantum Gravity
- There is a genuine conflict—the firewall paradox, a sharpened black hole information paradox—between the outside observer's view (information comes out, so it must be stored on the horizon like a membrane) and general relativity's insistence that an infalling observer crosses the horizon and finds nothing special; physicists care about both quantum mechanics and gravity, and there is currently no resolution that fully preserves both principles.218 | Raphael Bousso on Black Holes and the Holographic Universe
- General relativity is absolutely insistent that crossing the horizon of a large black hole is like any other empty space—there is no sign, no slap, nothing special—so we should be able to cross the horizon of a very large black hole right now without knowing it; this smoothness is what conflicts with the membrane/firewall picture.218 | Raphael Bousso on Black Holes and the Holographic Universe
- Bousso argues that Susskind's complementarity-style approach concedes that black holes can in fact have firewalls (just trying to avoid them for freshly-formed, not insanely old, black holes), and to Bousso this concession is unacceptable because once firewalls can exist at all it is a terrible affront to general relativity regardless of when they appear, and we have no idea what the dynamics of firewall formation would be.218 | Raphael Bousso on Black Holes and the Holographic Universe
- When two deep physical principles conflict, this is a great opportunity for progress, but a resolution should come down on one side—breaking quantum mechanics or gravity decisively—rather than breaking both 'a little bit'; Bousso argues approaches that allow firewalls even in old black holes are an unacceptable affront to general relativity, and the worst approaches violate both.218 | Raphael Bousso on Black Holes and the Holographic Universe