fine-tuning argument
An argument for a designer or God based on the observation that the physical constants of the universe appear precisely set to allow life.
As defined in AMA | August 2024
Where it comes up · 3
- AMA | July 20222 claims
- 223 - A Conversation With Andrew Sullivan1 claim
- AMA | August 20241 claim
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “fine-tuning argument” →
- The fine-tuning argument is the best argument for God because it plays by Bayesian rules, but it still fails for two reasons: God would not need to fine-tune a universe for life since God could create life in any universe (the argument only works if you are already a naturalist), and a consistent Bayesian must consider all the other data, which makes theistic predictions diverge sharply from the universe we actually observe.AMA | July 2022
- The fine-tuning argument's claimed probabilities (like 10^-223 for a life-supporting universe) are entirely bogus because the probability distributions for physical constants are simply made up, treated as independent when they are not, and assume both that we can calculate the probability of a universe like ours and that we know the probability life can exist—all unjustified; particle physicists make the same error.AMA | July 2022
- The fine-tuning argument is the best argument for the existence of God, yet it remains a bad argument; it is more plausible that life evolves and adapts under given conditions than that conditions were precisely tuned for life.AMA | August 2024
- Trump is not the worst possible person because the traits that make figures like Hitler worse—courage, competence, commitment to something beyond the self—are actually virtues; evil is amplified by virtues, so Trump's having all his traits dialed to their least respectable settings paradoxically limits his destructiveness relative to a competent, self-sacrificing malevolent actor.223 - A Conversation With Andrew Sullivan