feedback
A process by which the climate system's own response to warming (e.g. ice melt, water evaporation, vegetation change) either amplifies (positive) or dampens (negative) the warming.
As defined in 65 | Michael Mann on Why Our Climate Is Changing and How We Know
Where it comes up · 6
- 240 | Andrew Pontzen on Simulations and the Universe8 claims
- 33 | James Ladyman on Reality, Metaphysics, and Complexity2 claims
- 65 | Michael Mann on Why Our Climate Is Changing and How We Know2 claims
- How Better Feedback Can Revolutionize Education (with Daisy Christodoulou)1 claim
- 170 | Priya Natarajan on Galaxies, Black Holes, and Cosmic Anomalies1 claim
- 261 | Sanjana Curtis on the Origins of the Elements1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 15Search all claims for “feedback” →
- Recognizing that galaxies have internal life driven by supernova feedback forced a reinterpretation of cosmological observations: the late-1960s prediction that the universe would re-collapse in a Big Crunch—based on treating galaxies as inanimate standard markers—was overturned, paving the way for the modern understanding that the universe will likely expand forever at an accelerating rate.240 | Andrew Pontzen on Simulations and the Universe
- The biggest source of uncertainty in simulations is the 'sub-grid': because computers can only divide the universe into a finite number of grid cells, crucial processes happening below that resolution (like star formation or convection-driven clouds in weather) cannot emerge naturally, so simulators must add hand-crafted rules and tune them against real observations until the virtual universe resembles the real one.240 | Andrew Pontzen on Simulations and the Universe
- Black hole formation and growth are difficult to simulate because they are sub-grid problems: stellar-mass black holes form at the end of star lives (already uncertain), and black holes grow by eating surroundings at rates that can't be directly resolved, while the energy released by feeding can blow away other gas—an extraordinarily complex feedback process that cannot simply be observed by zooming into a simulation.240 | Andrew Pontzen on Simulations and the Universe
- The Hubble Deep Field in the mid-1990s—pointing the telescope for a week at an apparently empty patch of sky to reveal it full of distant galaxies—was initially a catastrophe for simulators because predictions had said it would contain bright, large galaxies; the discrepancy was eventually traced not to a failure of the dark matter framework but to incorrect treatment of how and when stars form (sub-grid feedback details).240 | Andrew Pontzen on Simulations and the Universe
- Although the universe's baryonic matter is mostly hydrogen and helium, the way stars form, explode, and inject both energy and new elements shapes how galaxies evolve—supernovae can even shove material out of a galaxy—so the heavier elements matter greatly to the structural history of the universe.261 | Sanjana Curtis on the Origins of the Elements
- Individual supernova events critically shape galaxy evolution because the energy they pump into surrounding gas heats it, can expel it from the galaxy, and suppresses future star formation (since gas must be cold to form stars), meaning galaxies are dynamic systems with internal life rather than passive collections of stars.240 | Andrew Pontzen on Simulations and the Universe
- Although central black holes are gravitationally minor, they play an outsized role by heating infalling gas: as gas is gobbled it speeds up, heats, and radiates, and that heat can prevent the gas cooling needed to form stars, so black holes act as energy sources that modulate (promote or suppress) the efficiency of star formation and thereby shape how a galaxy looks.170 | Priya Natarajan on Galaxies, Black Holes, and Cosmic Anomalies
- Ignoring sub-grid processes is doubly dangerous because they have feedback effects on the rest of the system: in weather, unmodeled clouds block sunlight, change ground temperatures, and alter winds, so missing the small-scale process corrupts the entire forecast—illustrating why small-scale physics cannot simply be neglected.240 | Andrew Pontzen on Simulations and the Universe
- Dark matter explains the overall shape of galaxy rotation curves to first order, but as an emergent phenomenon requiring simulations to predict, rather than something derivable a priori from the theory; modified gravity additionally challenges dark matter to explain why rotation curves show so little scatter across galaxies despite dark matter being distributed differently in each, an open question Pontzen attributes to feedback mechanisms.240 | Andrew Pontzen on Simulations and the Universe
- The low scatter and regularity in galaxy rotation phenomenology under dark matter is probably explained by feedback relationships—where too many stars produce supernovae that expel gas and suppress further star formation, plus feedback from supermassive black holes at galactic centers—though this is not fully understood.240 | Andrew Pontzen on Simulations and the Universe