experiencing self
Kahneman's term for the part of the mind that registers moment-to-moment pleasure and pain as they happen.
As defined in 94 | Stuart Russell on Making Artificial Intelligence Compatible with Humans
Where it comes up · 8
- 150 - The Map Of Misunderstanding3 claims
- 266 - The Limits Of Pleasure3 claims
- The Long Game: A Conversation with Robert Waldinger (Episode #308)2 claims
- 196 - The Science Of Happiness2 claims
- 446 - How To Do The Most Good2 claims
- 80 | Jenann Ismael on Connecting Physics to the World of Experience2 claims
- Ask Me Anything 151 claim
- 94 | Stuart Russell on Making Artificial Intelligence Compatible with Humans1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 16Search all claims for “experiencing self” →
- There are two selves: the experiencing self that lives life moment to moment, and the remembering self that evaluates life retrospectively; the cold-water experiment shows people prefer a longer painful episode that ends better over a shorter one with the same start, proving memory follows different rules from experience and that decisions are made by the remembering self even though the experiencing self does the living.150 - The Map Of Misunderstanding
- The Kahneman-Deaton finding that emotional well-being plateaus at $75,000/year is misleading: $75,000 already puts one in the global top 1%, so up to that point money clearly buys happiness for nearly everyone, and beyond it the retrospective measure of life satisfaction continues rising with income—so money is essential to happiness by virtually every measure.Ask Me Anything 15
- Human lives have two relatively independent dimensions of value: the aggregate quality of experienced moments, and a separate dimension tied to plans, projects, and relationships extending over time that keeps past and future in mind; the second is largely orthogonal to moment-quality, and we weigh them against each other in everyday decisions like how to spend a day.80 | Jenann Ismael on Connecting Physics to the World of Experience
- Kahneman's research shows humans have two selves—an experiencing self registering moment-to-moment pleasure or pain, and a remembering self that, contrary to standard economic theory, does not sum experiences but weights heavily the most intense (peak) and most recent (end) parts; this peak-end pattern may actually be rational once memory and expectation are folded into how the costs and benefits of an experience are evaluated.94 | Stuart Russell on Making Artificial Intelligence Compatible with Humans
- Kahneman abandoned his cherished view that the experiencing self is reality and the remembering self mere construction, because people actually want good memories and life satisfaction, not optimized experiences, and you cannot have a theory of well-being that doesn't correspond to what people want.150 - The Map Of Misunderstanding
- The famous Kahneman-Deaton finding is half-told: beyond about $75,000 money stops improving moment-to-moment experienced well-being, but the other index—retrospective life satisfaction from the remembering self—keeps rising with wealth all the way up, with millionaires happier than the merely rich and people with $10 million happier than those with $1 million, likely driven by relative social status among primates.266 - The Limits Of Pleasure
- Harris argues against Kahneman's claim that the experiencing and remembering selves cannot be reconciled, contending that the remembering self is just the experiencing self in a particular mode, and that retrospective satisfaction judgments themselves have downstream effects on ongoing experience, so they all occur within one timeline and can in principle be summed.266 - The Limits Of Pleasure
- Against Kahneman's suggestion that evaluating life from the remembering self involves a kind of inauthenticity (just telling a good story), the better view is that there are genuinely two orthogonal dimensions of value that we authentically weigh against one another at every moment, so the remembering-self perspective is not a distortion of the experiencing-self perspective.80 | Jenann Ismael on Connecting Physics to the World of Experience
- Kahneman's research shows duration neglect: an eight-hour unpleasant flight is genuinely twice as bad as a four-hour one in actual experienced misery, yet people remember them as about equally bad, and a two-week versus one-week vacation are remembered the same despite the experiential difference.266 - The Limits Of Pleasure
- There can be a real difference between what you think you enjoy and what you actually enjoy in the moment, so people should track their in-the-moment experiences rather than relying solely on retrospective judgments—otherwise they risk sacrificing the moments of their life for the story of their life, giving each momentary self a bad deal.446 - How To Do The Most Good