expansionary austerity
Episodes in which budget/spending cuts are associated with rising rather than falling growth, because the contractionary Keynesian effect is small and outweighed by expectations, confidence, and supply-side effects
As defined in Alberto Alesina on Fiscal Policy and Austerity
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “expansionary austerity” →
- Across episodes of austerity, spending-based fiscal consolidations have close to zero average output cost and have sometimes been expansionary, whereas tax-based consolidations have produced recessions of 2-3% of GDP lasting 2-3 years — a large and robust asymmetry that any unbiased observer would acknowledge.Alberto Alesina on Fiscal Policy and Austerity
- Although the IMF in 2010 wrote a pointed criticism of Alesina's work, after all the research was done the IMF's own published paper acknowledged that spending cuts are much less costly than tax increases — the fundamental result on which Alesina's work is based — making Krugman's claim that the work was discredited wrong.Alberto Alesina on Fiscal Policy and Austerity
- Empirical evidence shows that during spending cuts investor confidence rises while consumer confidence falls only slightly, whereas during tax increases both consumer and business confidence drop substantially — so confidence is one of several real channels driving the asymmetry, not a mythical 'confidence fairy.'Alberto Alesina on Fiscal Policy and Austerity
- Expansionary austerity — where spending cuts are accompanied by increasing rather than declining growth because the small Keynesian contraction is more than compensated by other effects — has occurred in real episodes including Denmark and Ireland in the 1980s, Canada and Belgium and Finland in the 1990s, and the UK during the financial crisis.Alberto Alesina on Fiscal Policy and Austerity