exclusionary rule
A legal rule that bars reliable evidence from trial if police obtained it through an improper search or seizure.
As defined in Paul Robinson on Cooperation, Punishment and the Criminal Justice System
Where it comes up · 2
- Paul Robinson on Cooperation, Punishment and the Criminal Justice System3 claims
- Rachel Harmon2 claims
Most important claims · 5 of 5Search all claims for “exclusionary rule” →
- The exclusionary rule has profoundly changed police culture by giving departments an incentive to teach officers constitutional law and officers an incentive to learn and follow it; before the rule officers knew nothing about constitutional law, after it every officer treats the Fourth Amendment as part of his manual—illustrated by a corrupt cop who still wouldn't fabricate probable cause because that was the part subject to the rule.Rachel Harmon
- There are almost no consequences for police officers who lie: under the exclusionary rule the worst outcome of an officer lying at a suppression hearing is the evidence being suppressed—exactly what would have happened had he told the truth—so lying is a costless gamble, while internally, departments often fail to act and officers who admit lying learn that admission is more punished than the lie itself.Rachel Harmon
- The exclusionary rule responds to police misconduct by suppressing reliable evidence and freeing guilty defendants, which is the wrong punishment because police would rather have a conviction and do not much care what happens to the offender; directly sanctioning the officer (even minor unpaid suspensions) would deter misconduct more effectively while avoiding the justice-frustrating cost of letting criminals go.Paul Robinson on Cooperation, Punishment and the Criminal Justice System
- Unlike the United States' rigid, all-or-nothing exclusionary rule, European courts balance the unfairness to the defendant against the seriousness of the police violation and the offense, asking how society is better off; as a result, despite this more flexible approach, surveys show Europeans rate the fairness of their criminal justice systems higher than Americans do.Paul Robinson on Cooperation, Punishment and the Criminal Justice System
- Because police culture views the exclusionary rule as essentially immoral, officers who would never otherwise lie about a criminal case consider it morally acceptable to lie in court about the circumstances of a search or seizure to avoid the rule's application—a practice New York officers labeled 'testilying.'Paul Robinson on Cooperation, Punishment and the Criminal Justice System