epiphenomenal
A byproduct that accompanies a process but does not itself cause the outcome.
As defined in Alison Gopnik
Where it comes up · 5
- Michael Munger on Constitutions2 claims
- AMA | May 20252 claims
- Alison Gopnik1 claim
- 154 | Reza Aslan on Religion, Metaphor, and Meaning1 claim
- Sam Harris and Richard Dawkins in Conversation1 claim
Most important claims · 7 of 7Search all claims for “epiphenomenal” →
- The Doomsday Argument and related anthropic/self-locating uncertainty arguments subtly depend on some set of subjectivity or consciousness metaphysics, because if 'we' are merely an epiphenomenal emergent property, it is unclear in what sense we find ourselves to be here and now.AMA | May 2025
- By 1980 Buchanan abandoned the view that the U.S. Constitution caused American success, holding instead that it was important as a focal point but not causal; words on paper everyone has agreed to (like 'all men are created equal' or the Magna Carta) matter even when not true or enforced, because they can be used as a bludgeon to hold people to what they claimed to believe.Michael Munger on Constitutions
- If consciousness is real but has no causal power, it is hard to see how something without causal power could create felt experience, and it appears logically contradictory that we could still be talking about consciousness at all if it were genuinely non-causal.AMA | May 2025
- De Jasay argued there are only two possibilities for a constitution: either everyone believes in its embodied principles, making it unnecessary, or few do, making it ineffective; thus the constitution is largely epiphenomenal—what matters is people's attitudes toward it, and if no one believes in it there will always be a workaround.Michael Munger on Constitutions
- Aslan holds that the laws of physics are incomplete because they are not cognisant of the cognitive abilities of the brain to experience transcendence beyond the material realm, and that as we expand our understanding of the universe we will have to rewrite those laws.154 | Reza Aslan on Religion, Metaphor, and Meaning
- Consciousness may be epiphenomenal—that is, not actually doing anything causally efficacious, with all brain functions accomplishable in the dark while consciousness is merely the spotlight effect of processes engineered neurophysiologicallySam Harris and Richard Dawkins in Conversation
- Aphantasia shows that the experience of generating a mental image when solving a problem is epiphenomenal—you are not solving the problem by viewing an internal picture; people like Pixar co-founder Ed Catmull animate without seeing pictures in their heads, while the underlying cognitive work of generating a visual representation occurs without the visual-cortex feedback that produces the felt image.Alison Gopnik