enshittification
The gradual degradation of an online platform's quality as it prioritizes extracting value over serving users.
As defined in 341 | Stewart Brand on Maintenance as an Organizing Principle
Other definitions
A process by which online platforms and products start useful and user-friendly but gradually degrade as they prioritize company profit over user value, typically through forced upgrades, added advertisements, reduced access to original features, and extraction of value from users
Authors of "THE AI CON" discussing the problematic hype about AI & what those working tech should do
Where it comes up · 4
- We Didn’t Ask for This Internet | The Ezra Klein Show5 claims
- Authors of "THE AI CON" discussing the problematic hype about AI & what those working tech should do3 claims
- Conversations with Tyler - Craig Newmark1 claim
- 341 | Stewart Brand on Maintenance as an Organizing Principle1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 10Search all claims for “enshittification” →
- Chat GPT was not 'bad on arrival' like the enshittification argument might suggest; instead, it was useful initially, but as capital demands limitless growth, it becomes subject to enshittification—a trajectory predicted by the theory applied to LLMs.Authors of "THE AI CON" discussing the problematic hype about AI & what those working tech should do
- Enshittification happens when Chat GPT moves from optional to mandatory at work despite inability to validate outputs—workers cannot take time to quality-check because they'd be left behind, creating a forced choice between using unreliable tools or being deemed unproductive.Authors of "THE AI CON" discussing the problematic hype about AI & what those working tech should do
- Tech workers were historically a restraining force on platform enshittification because they were scarce, valued, and often cared about users, giving them leverage to refuse to build bad things. However, they viewed themselves as temporarily embarrassed founders rather than workers and didn't unionize, so when labor scarcity ended, they lost bargaining power.We Didn’t Ask for This Internet | The Ezra Klein Show
- In stage two of enshittification on Facebook, advertisers are told 'We lied about not spying on users; we spy on them from to appetite. Pay us and we'll target ads with exquisite fidelity.' Advertisers and publishers pile in and become locked to the platform.We Didn’t Ask for This Internet | The Ezra Klein Show
- Tim Wu's counterargument to Doctorow: platforms like Meta have actually been under competitive pressure from TikTok, stole features from TikTok and Snapchat, and improved as a result. Saying this isn't enshittification but rather the magic of competition.We Didn’t Ask for This Internet | The Ezra Klein Show
- Enshittification is a label for both an observation about a characteristic pattern of how platforms degrade and why platforms degrade now, because something has changed—not that greed was newly invented in the middle of the last decade.We Didn’t Ask for This Internet | The Ezra Klein Show
- Brand predicts we will spend much of our time arguing with AI robots because they operate on assumptions about a situation that may not match yours, requiring you to persuade the AI that it has answered a question you didn't ask; this arguing is itself instructive, and the reliable-information ecosystem like YouTube will need maintenance against AI-generated nonsense and 'enshittification.'341 | Stewart Brand on Maintenance as an Organizing Principle
- Enshittification occurs when a product that starts useful becomes degraded as companies prioritize profit over user benefit; LLMs like ChatGPT might not be enshittified on arrival but could follow this pattern as companies make their use mandatory for workers while removing the ability to validate outputs.Authors of "THE AI CON" discussing the problematic hype about AI & what those working tech should do
- Successful sites had to compete harder over time, which forced them to attract venture capital, whose escalating demands pushed operators to extract as many dollars as possible from users, beginning the process Cory Doctorow calls 'enshittification.'Conversations with Tyler - Craig Newmark
- When you unshackle firms from the four forces of discipline (competitors, regulators, workforce, new market entry through interoperability), the same CEOs who would normally be constrained pull the 'enshittification switch' as hard as they can, and it goes from zero to 100 because the policy environment has lubricated it to function freely.We Didn’t Ask for This Internet | The Ezra Klein Show