engineered indexes
Custom-designed stock market indexes created by third parties (often index providers) with proprietary algorithms that combine multiple asset classes and volatility-control mechanisms, designed specifically for insurance companies to manage options costs
As defined in Danger Alert: The 7 Risks of Proprietary Indexes In IUL
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 10 of 15Search all claims for “engineered indexes” →
- Engineered indexes used in IULs typically use multiple asset classes and sophisticated algorithms to control volatility, but these algorithms lack transparency and operate as black boxes investors cannot understand.Danger Alert: The 7 Risks of Proprietary Indexes In IUL
- Engineered indexes carry additional management fees, performance fees, and algorithm fees not present in traditional indexes (S&P 500, Dow Jones, Russell 2000), creating systematic erosion of illustrated returns and actual policy cash value over time.Danger Alert: The 7 Risks of Proprietary Indexes In IUL
- Traditional indexes (S&P 500, Dow Jones, Russell 2000) do not include the additional fees, costs, and algorithm complexity that engineered indexes carry.Danger Alert: The 7 Risks of Proprietary Indexes In IUL
- Between 2011 and 2024, the number of companies selling index universal life insurance grew from 14 to over 70, a 5x increase that created supply-demand imbalance in the options market, driving up options costs and forcing insurance companies to develop proprietary engineered indexes to manage costs.Danger Alert: The 7 Risks of Proprietary Indexes In IUL
- Index components and rules within engineered indexes can change unilaterally by the insurance company, and indexes can be completely eliminated from future policy options without consumer consent, creating hidden lapse risk for existing policyholders.Danger Alert: The 7 Risks of Proprietary Indexes In IUL
- Volatility-controlled indexes used in some IULs experienced severe underperformance during market stress periods (specifically citing post-COVID), suggesting their algorithms struggle to adapt to extreme market conditions outside the historical lookback period.Danger Alert: The 7 Risks of Proprietary Indexes In IUL
- Engineered indexes are typically created using 20-30 year lookbacks of historical market data, allowing creators to cherry-pick favorable historical conditions that may not repeat in the future, creating performance uncertainty when future market conditions differ from past conditions.Danger Alert: The 7 Risks of Proprietary Indexes In IUL
- Understanding the mechanics of engineered indexes, underlying assets, variables, and policy shifts is essential and should be a prerequisite for purchasing cash value life insurance.Danger Alert: The 7 Risks of Proprietary Indexes In IUL
- Fee structures and costs is the fifth of seven dangers of engineered indexes within IULs.Danger Alert: The 7 Risks of Proprietary Indexes In IUL
- Proprietary nature and changing index components is the fourth of seven dangers of engineered indexes within IULs.Danger Alert: The 7 Risks of Proprietary Indexes In IUL