elite overproduction
A condition (drawn from Goldstone and Turchin) in which a society produces more people who believe they should be elites than it has positions or rewards to satisfy them, generating frustration and unrest.
As defined in Musa al-Gharbi
Other definitions
Structural imbalance where the number of people aspiring to elite status and wealth (measured by those with $10M+ net worth) grows exponentially while the number of elite power positions (e.g., executive roles, political offices) remains fixed, creating competition and rule-breaking behavior
U.S. On Brink Of Another 'Revolution'; What Happens Next | Peter Turchin
Where it comes up · 7
- Understanding Societal Collapse with Complexity Scientist Peter Turchin6 claims
- How do elites pave the way for social decay? | Peter Turchin x Brain Bar4 claims
- U.S. On Brink Of Another 'Revolution'; What Happens Next | Peter Turchin4 claims
- Musa al-Gharbi3 claims
- 294 - Status Games1 claim
- 259 - The Reckoning To Come1 claim
- Samo Burja - The Great Founder Theory of History - [Invest Like the Best, EP.339]1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 20Search all claims for “elite overproduction” →
- Elite overproduction—a situation where too many people vie for a fixed number of power positions—is one of the most important forces driving societies into periods of political instability and crisis, as demonstrated by historical cases like the Russian Revolution, French Revolution, English Civil War, and the Thirty Years' War.How do elites pave the way for social decay? | Peter Turchin x Brain Bar
- The academic science establishment is simultaneously too elitist (it is a pain to publish in major journals and it focuses on prestige over replication) and not elitist enough (it is largely an academic jobs program of underpaid PhDs doing lab-tech work); cheap labor delayed biomedical automation, and the better model is instant publication like arXiv plus crypto crowdfunding for research.259 - The Reckoning To Come
- Peter Turchin's cliodynamics and elite-overproduction models capture real historical patterns, but these patterns hold only until they break, and breaks are often caused by great founders, which statistical models cannot predict.Samo Burja - The Great Founder Theory of History - [Invest Like the Best, EP.339]
- Elite overproduction is the common precursor to societal crisis—a dynamic where the number of elite aspirants and wealth holders grows exponentially (by 10-fold in the US since 1980) while the number of elite power positions remains fixed (one president, 100 senators), creating 'masses of angry losers' willing to break rulesU.S. On Brink Of Another 'Revolution'; What Happens Next | Peter Turchin
- There are hundreds of examples of societal elite-driven revolutions in history (Russian, Cuban, Chinese, taiping, American Civil War, French Revolution), demonstrating elite overproduction and conflict is a recurrent mechanismU.S. On Brink Of Another 'Revolution'; What Happens Next | Peter Turchin
- Democratic institutions genuinely work, and while living in a democratic society does not provide immunity to elite overproduction and crisis, it gives a better chance of avoiding the worst outcomes.How do elites pave the way for social decay? | Peter Turchin x Brain Bar
- Highly educated, wealthy progressive activists—a tiny sliver who nonetheless produce more social media content than all other groups combined—are experiencing status decline because the financial crisis, falling incomes, debt, and 'elite overproduction' (too many elites for too few elite positions) deny them success-based status, pushing them toward moralistic virtue games to acquire status instead.294 - Status Games
- Turchin has studied the Russian Revolution, Cuban Revolution, Taiping Rebellion in China, the US Civil War, and the French Revolution as historical cases of elite overproduction leading to crisis, with such events numbering in the hundreds even thousands across history.U.S. On Brink Of Another 'Revolution'; What Happens Next | Peter Turchin
- Trump is an exemplar of a 'billionaire counter-elite'—a wealthy outsider who mobilizes grievances of excluded populations to challenge incumbent elites and secure political position, exemplifying elite overproduction dynamics where frustrated wealthy aspirants use popular mobilization as a tool.Understanding Societal Collapse with Complexity Scientist Peter Turchin
- Awokenings tend to arise during acute moments of elite overproduction—when society produces more people who believe they should be elites than it can give the lives they feel they deserve—because these credentialed-but-frustrated aspirants grow dissatisfied and develop a motive to condemn the prevailing order and purge incumbents to make room for themselves.Musa al-Gharbi