effectual truth
Machiavelli's notion that a statement or thing should be judged by its actual effect or upshot rather than its stated intent or ideal; the basis for reasoning from cause to effect in modern empirical thinking.
As defined in Conversations with Tyler - Harvey Mansfield
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 3 of 3Search all claims for “effectual truth” →
- Machiavelli's notion of 'effectual truth'—judging a statement by its upshot or effect rather than its stated intent—is the fundamental notion behind modern science, because it shifts knowing away from wish or speech (as with Plato and Aristotle) toward fact, allowing reasoning from cause to effect.Conversations with Tyler - Harvey Mansfield
- Machiavelli's notion of indirect rule trains people to view politics conspiratorially—as what goes on behind the scenes rather than in its public justifications—which does encourage excessive attachment to conspiracy theories; the longest chapter in his two great works is on conspiracy, where he uniquely explains how to execute one in three stages.Conversations with Tyler - Harvey Mansfield
- Machiavelli exaggerates, so only a small percentage of his propositions would test as literally true, yet he is the author of empirical propositions and of knowledge-as-prediction; exaggeration is a requirement of empirical analysis rather than its enemy, because understanding how people act differently from what they say lets you reduce the realm of fortune or chance and make your hoped-for outcome a fact.Conversations with Tyler - Harvey Mansfield