earning to give
A strategy of taking a high-earning career specifically to donate a large share of income to effective causes.
As defined in Rob Wiblin and Russ Roberts on Charity, Science, and Utilitarianism
Where it comes up · 15
- 342 - Animal Minds Moral Truths3 claims
- 228 - Doing Good3 claims
- Sam Bankman-Fried - Crypto, Altruism, and Leadership2 claims
- 448 - The Philosophy Of Good And Evil2 claims
- Vaccine Mandates Transgender Athletes Billionaires Ama 192 claims
- Animal Minds & Moral Truths: A Conversation with Peter Singer (Episode #342)1 claim
- Making Your 80,000 Hours Count (with Benjamin Todd)1 claim
- William MacAskill on Effective Altruism and Doing Good Better1 claim
and 7 more
Most important claims · 10 of 22Search all claims for “earning to give” →
- For perhaps 15% of people, the best way to do good is 'earning to give'—deliberately taking a lucrative career to donate—because of comparative advantage (some have valuable but charity-irrelevant skills), the ability to target the most effective charities, money's flexibility to switch as evidence changes (unlike labor), and the value of building business skills before moving into the nonprofit sector.William MacAskill on Effective Altruism and Doing Good Better
- Society applies a perverse double standard to charity: it would be irrational to fault a venture for spending 30% on overhead to raise $400 million versus 5% to raise only $10 million if the funds are used well, and it is bizarre to praise someone for getting rich in a frivolous career while condemning a charity leader for earning millions to cure cancer or save the vulnerable—this filters charity leadership for sainthood rather than competence.228 - Doing Good
- The Giving What We Can pledge is based not on the absolute amount donated but on the percentage of pre-tax earnings—a minimum of 10% to highly effective charities—so even someone earning $30,000 a year can take it.Vaccine Mandates Transgender Athletes Billionaires Ama 19
- The popular image of effective altruism as merely earning maximum money to donate to GiveWell global-health charities misconstrues it in three ways: causes have broadened (future generations, existential risk, animal welfare, AI), most adherents now do good primarily through career choice rather than donations, and EA is best understood as a research methodology and evolving project rather than a fixed set of recommendations.228 - Doing Good
- Through 80,000 Hours, effective altruists realized that time is one's other major asset and that for many people the best way to do good is 'earning to give'—making as much money as possible by ethical means and donating it to effective charities—because money is the truly fungible resource, so a talented earner who gives away large sums (like Warren Buffett) does more good than working directly for a charity.448 - The Philosophy Of Good And Evil
- Whether the best contribution is direct work or 'earning to give' depends on each cause's bottleneck: in fields like AI safety, pandemic preparedness, and scientific research there is more demand for competent altruistic people than money, so direct work dominates; whereas in global health and development, proven interventions could absorb hundreds of millions more dollars, making money the bottleneck and earning to give more valuable.228 - Doing Good
- Effective altruism, founded by Toby Ord and Will MacAskill in Oxford around 2009 with Giving What We Can, built on Singer's thought experiment by adding the insight that giving effectively matters as much or more than giving: the most effective charities can be 100 to 1,000 times more effective than typical or least-effective ones, so a person giving £5,000 to a charity that saves a life for £5,000 does more good than someone giving £495,000 to a charity that needs £500,000 to save a life.448 - The Philosophy Of Good And Evil
- Earning to give means taking a morally neutral or positive high-earning career and donating the money to enable people who are a better fit for direct work to have a big impact; it is rarely recommended by conventional impact advice but suits people who fit corporate careers, as illustrated by Fred Mulder who became an art dealer and funded tens of charity-sector jobs.Making Your 80,000 Hours Count (with Benjamin Todd)
- Even committed consequentialists must obey accepted rules of good conduct; the SBF collapse shows that thinking oneself a genius who can take shortcuts (like borrowing clients' trust funds) is very dangerous and never worth the risk, regardless of one's good intentions—analogous to the discipline of checking a firearm repeatedly.342 - Animal Minds Moral Truths
- 80,000 Hours advises people to contribute to pressing global problems judged by scale (how many affected and how much), neglectedness (low-hanging fruit), and tractability, then to seek leverage by addressing the binding bottleneck—ideas, money, or skills—often via government policy or fundamental research, while finding a role of strong personal fit and building career capital early.Rob Wiblin and Russ Roberts on Charity, Science, and Utilitarianism