differential treatment effect
The gap in treatment effectiveness between catching a disease early versus late; screening only provides value when treating early disease is much more effective than treating advanced disease
As defined in Vinay Prasad on Cancer Screening
Where it comes up · 1
- Vinay Prasad on Cancer Screening2 claims
Most important claims · 2 of 2Search all claims for “differential treatment effect” →
- Screening only works when there is a differential treatment effect: a large benefit from treating early-stage disease versus late-stage disease. In testicle cancer, advanced disease is curable at 95-97%, so there is no differential to exploit and screening is unnecessary (USPSTF Grade D); as treatments for advanced breast and prostate cancer improve, the differential shrinks and screening's benefit erodes.Vinay Prasad on Cancer Screening
- Every mammographic randomized trial likely overstates current benefit because treatments have improved dramatically since the trials (around 30 new breast cancer drugs, better surgery, radiation, scanning, and supportive care); as treatment for advanced disease improves, the differential effect screening exploits shrinks, eroding whatever benefit existed.Vinay Prasad on Cancer Screening