cultural group selection
The idea that cultures or groups compete, and those with traits that help survival and reproduction spread, so culture itself is shaped by competition among groups.
As defined in Roy Baumeister on Gender Differences and Culture 11/14/2011
Other definitions
The idea that selection operates on cultures or communities of people (rather than genes), so that culturally beneficial traits like moralizing religion spread because the groups carrying them thrive.
Paul Bloom
Where it comes up · 2
Most important claims · 6 of 6Search all claims for “cultural group selection” →
- Culture is humanity's biological strategy for survival and reproduction: nature evolved humans to create culture, and cultures that accumulate knowledge and trade networks prevailed over competing groups, which is why roughly 200 countries exist today rather than the many cultures that failed.Roy Baumeister on Gender Differences and Culture 11/14/2011
- Historically, cultures that lost too many females would struggle to maintain the next generation, so cultures tend to send men into risk and combat while protecting women, and this asymmetry emerges as an adaptation of competing groups.Roy Baumeister on Gender Differences and Culture 11/14/2011
- Competition among groups in China reduced over a thousand autonomous local sovereign units to seven and then one, illustrating how political and military competition produces large cultural and institutional consolidation over centuries.Roy Baumeister on Gender Differences and Culture 11/14/2011
- Although polytheism is the cognitive default, monotheism has come to dominate because a single omniscient moralizing God serves moral and coordinating functions—binding communities and making people behave better even when unobserved—giving such societies an advantage through cultural group selection.Paul Bloom
- Group selection is implausible as a genetic evolutionary mechanism (as Dawkins argued, it could happen in principle but does not in practice), yet it is a reasonable framework when applied to cultures—some cultures do better and thrive—where the unit is communities of people rather than genes.Paul Bloom
- In modern societies, technology substitutes for population size, so the group competition that once selected for cultural traits operates through economics and innovation rather than physical conquest, making it harder for costly cultural changes to be punished quickly.Roy Baumeister on Gender Differences and Culture 11/14/2011