counter-elites
Elite aspirants who have been denied access to power positions and respond by breaking rules, pursuing violence, and challenging the existing social order; examples include revolutionary leaders and ambitious politicians excluded from conventional power
As defined in How do elites pave the way for social decay? | Peter Turchin x Brain Bar
Other definitions
Ambitious individuals with elite credentials (education, intelligence, ambition) who are excluded from elite positions due to overproduction and who become willing to organize social discontent and break rules to advance their power and position
U.S. On Brink Of Another 'Revolution'; What Happens Next | Peter Turchin
Where it comes up · 2
- U.S. On Brink Of Another 'Revolution'; What Happens Next | Peter Turchin5 claims
- How do elites pave the way for social decay? | Peter Turchin x Brain Bar2 claims
Most important claims · 7 of 7Search all claims for “counter-elites” →
- Frustrated elites who fail to secure power positions turn to rule-breaking and violence, becoming counter-elites; historical examples include Lenin and the Bolsheviks, Castro and the Barbudos, and present-day American dissidents trying to take over the Republican Party.How do elites pave the way for social decay? | Peter Turchin x Brain Bar
- Law schools produce lawyers at a 3:1 ratio to available legal positions, creating masses of ambitious, intelligent, rule-breaking counter-elites (citing Lenin, Castro, and Robespierre as examples).U.S. On Brink Of Another 'Revolution'; What Happens Next | Peter Turchin
- The most important part of revolution is whether ruling elites are overthrown and replaced by counter-elites, rather than the form it takes (violent or non-violent).U.S. On Brink Of Another 'Revolution'; What Happens Next | Peter Turchin
- The United States is overproducing law degrees by a factor of 3 to 1—three times as many law school graduates as available positions—and AI will further reduce legal positions by half, approaching a 6 to 1 overproduction ratio; lawyers are particularly dangerous counter-elites because they are ambitious, well-networked, well-organized, heavily indebted, as exemplified by Lenin, Castro, Robert Speer, Gandhi, and Lincoln.How do elites pave the way for social decay? | Peter Turchin x Brain Bar
- The 2024 US presidential election represents a kind of revolution—not yet bloody—but one in which the American ruling elites are in danger of being overthrown and replaced by counter-elitesU.S. On Brink Of Another 'Revolution'; What Happens Next | Peter Turchin
- When smart, well-networked, energetic, ambitious people are turned into counter-elites by AI job displacement, this is a recipe for disaster because they have the skills to organize revolutionary movements.U.S. On Brink Of Another 'Revolution'; What Happens Next | Peter Turchin
- Forces pushing the US toward instability have been building up for more than 40 years, and the US is currently in a revolutionary situation where society is fragile and violent outbreaks may happen, with the 2024 election representing a kind of non-bloody revolution in which ruling elites are in danger of being overthrown and replaced by counter-elites.U.S. On Brink Of Another 'Revolution'; What Happens Next | Peter Turchin