coordination problem
A situation where many actors would benefit from acting together but no individual can move first, so a large backer is needed to make a new city viable.
As defined in Why Housing Is Artificially Expensive and What Can Be Done About It (with Bryan Caplan)
Other definitions
A situation where many actors would all be better off if they acted in a coordinated way, but each has an incentive to act independently.
The Future of Tech
Where it comes up · 14
- 329 | Steven Pinker on Rationality and Common Knowledge4 claims
- 116 - Ai Racing Toward The Brink3 claims
- Jeremy Giffon - Special Situations in Private Markets - [Invest Like the Best, Replay]2 claims
- Conversation, Interintellect, and Arcadia (with Anna Gat)1 claim
- Peter Boettke on Katrina, Ten Years After1 claim
- Why Housing Is Artificially Expensive and What Can Be Done About It (with Bryan Caplan)1 claim
- 202 - A Conversation With Andrew Yang1 claim
- 400 - The Politics Of Information1 claim
and 6 more
Most important claims · 10 of 20Search all claims for “coordination problem” →
- Timur Kuran's work shows dictatorships are hard to predict the fall of because under repression people hide their true views (preference falsification); the first person to protest risks being mowed down, but once a few act the marginal risk for each additional joiner drops, so tiny variations in the distribution of bravery produce wildly different outcomes—a kind of political chaos theory and a coordination problem of epistemic solitude.160 - The Revenge Of History
- A coordination problem exists where a better arrangement is available but reaching it requires changing more than one thing at a time: buyers won't switch platforms without sellers and vice versa, and scientists can't abandon prestigious-but-exploitative journals one at a time because a lone new journal has low impact factor, so everyone must move simultaneously or no one moves.116 - Ai Racing Toward The Brink
- Coordination games are scenarios with common interest where players get shared payoffs by coordinating their behavior, but multiple ways to coordinate exist so the interesting question is how actors settle on one; bargaining games are a subclass concerning resource division (money, time, effort), which is ubiquitous in human life and requires coordination.113 | Cailin O'Connor on Game Theory, Evolution, and the Origins of Unfairness
- Civilizations can become crazy, stupid, or evil at the system level without any individual inside them being crazy, stupid, or evil; rather than evil cabals profiting from dysfunction, the truth is coordination problems where moving to a better state requires changing more than one thing simultaneously, so each person's locally rational choice keeps a suboptimal equilibrium in place.116 - Ai Racing Toward The Brink
- Reopening schools is central to disaster recovery because returning workers face a coordination problem ('I'll come back if you come back'); a St. Bernard Parish superintendent acted entrepreneurially within the public system to reopen a school in 8 months instead of the projected 18, helping restore the normalcy needed for residents to return and rebuild.Peter Boettke on Katrina, Ten Years After
- Despite enormous cultural and geopolitical upheaval over the past eleven years—Brexit, Trump, a pandemic, wars—the basic human need for one another never changes; AI will be an enormous break but cannot raise the barn, raise your children, or have the kind of conversation in which two people reach a new level of self-understanding, because so much of life is a coordination problem.Conversation, Interintellect, and Arcadia (with Anna Gat)
- Traffic is a coordination problem, and if everyone's departure times were jittered or staggered—even randomly—traffic jams would be greatly reduced, because just a few people delaying their arrival by five minutes lets the other 90% arrive on time.466 - What Is Technology Doing To Us
- Only a tiny, probably single-digit percentage of the Democratic Party ever truly believed the woke positions, but they were so loud and the reputational consequences of crossing them so excruciating that everyone fell into line—posting black squares and declaring pronouns—so the remaining challenge is solving the coordination problem of convincing everyone at once that the activists no longer need to be appeased.400 - The Politics Of Information
- Our political and social failures are largely not due to many bad people or radically conflicting desires but to coordination problems—badly aligned incentives where people cannot agree to change their behavior simultaneously even when doing so would benefit everyone, a game-theoretic situation of being stuck in a suboptimal Nash equilibrium; the solution is better ideas, messaging, and stories, but the resulting changes must be institutionalized and inscribed in culture so that ordinary people don't have to be saints each morning.124 - In Search Of Reality
- A maximum-security prison illustrates a perversely bad equilibrium: regardless of your own ethics, the structure makes it your best available choice to join a race-aligned gang, because failing to do so leaves you preyed upon by everyone—an example of how incentive structures, not individual character, force people into terrible behavior.116 - Ai Racing Toward The Brink