convex hull
Smallest convex set containing a set of points; here used for the set of results reachable by linear combinations of known ideas.
As defined in Lex Fridman Podcast #503 - AI Crisis in Math
Other definitions
In geometry, the smallest convex region enclosing a set of points; used metaphorically to describe the geographic area Harvard's institutions spread across.
Paul Graham
Where it comes up · 3
- Lex Fridman Podcast #503 - AI Crisis in Math4 claims
- 280 | François Chollet on Deep Learning and the Meaning of Intelligence2 claims
- Paul Graham1 claim
Most important claims · 7 of 7Search all claims for “convex hull” →
- Because LLM transformations are vector programs, you can average or interpolate between them—asking it to talk like a pirate and like Shakespeare simultaneously yields a Shakespearean pirate—which is something you cannot do with an explicit logic program, giving the impression of creativity through interpolation within the convex hull of training representations.280 | François Chollet on Deep Learning and the Meaning of Intelligence
- Real invention and creativity by an algorithm has historically occurred only when an open-ended search process operates over a relatively unconstrained search space; LLMs cannot invent anything because they are limited to interpolations, whereas genetic algorithms with the right search space and fitness function can invent entirely novel systems no human could anticipate—such as the famously novel antenna design.280 | François Chollet on Deep Learning and the Meaning of Intelligence
- Moitra argues that AI-produced results change the boundary of the balloon, not just its interior, because the field-altering results change the questions researchers choose and how they conceive the landscape, so the direction of interesting work is permanently different.Lex Fridman Podcast #503 - AI Crisis in Math
- Kontorovich argues that the AI's moves should be understood as a semigroup action on known tools rather than a derogatory convex hull: combinations of known ideas can reach much farther than linear combinations inside a bounded region, though whether this counts as new is interpretive.Lex Fridman Podcast #503 - AI Crisis in Math
- Brunton argues the AI results are a lift of fog over the existing convex hull, making machines interpolate and reveal the opaque interior of human knowledge, but he also thinks they are more extrapolatory than merely derogatory recombination.Lex Fridman Podcast #503 - AI Crisis in Math
- YC was deliberately built as the 'Harvard of startups,' located within the convex hull of Harvard's spread through Cambridge, consciously copying the model of concentrating talent selection in a small magnet area to draw people in and produce winners.Paul Graham
- Kontorovich pictures known results as a balloon whose interior is the convex hull; AI operating inside it has not expanded the boundary, but new definitions by humans push the boundary outward.Lex Fridman Podcast #503 - AI Crisis in Math