Sheela
Sheela
Home
Add
Questions
Thinkers
Claims
People
Concepts
Jargon
Sources
Health
Predictions
Collections
Domain Landscape
Contribute
Review
Dedup
Topic requests
Settings
Help

← Jargon

Jargonphilosophy· 2 claims· 2 episodes

contra-causal free will

Free will understood as the genuine ability to act outside the deterministic causal chain; Rosenberg holds this is the only thing real free will could be, and that it does not exist.

As defined in 125 | David Haig on the Evolution of Meaning from Darwin to Derrida


Where it comes up · 2
  • 91 - The Biology Of Good And Evil1 claim
  • 125 | David Haig on the Evolution of Meaning from Darwin to Derrida1 claim

Most important claims · 2 of 2Search all claims for “contra-causal free will” →
  • Even without free will, people's behavior can be modified by reasons, reinforcement, and punishment; it is rational to feel frustration during the discovery process of trying to reason with someone, and to invoke punishment instrumentally, because nervous systems—from sea slugs to humans—are demonstrably conditioned by input, all without attributing contra-causal free will.91 - The Biology Of Good And Evil
  • Free will does not exist; hard determinism is true or true enough to deprive us of it, and there is no way to reconcile determinism with a watered-down compatibilist conception of free will as Hume and others have tried; our subjective experience of free will merely deceives us.125 | David Haig on the Evolution of Meaning from Darwin to Derrida