constitutive rules
Rules that constitute and define the behavior they govern rather than merely regulating pre-existing behavior; the behavior consists in following the rules (e.g., the rules of chess constitute what counts as playing chess)
As defined in The Logical Structure of Human Civilization (John Searle)
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “constitutive rules” →
- Constitutive rules are rules that constitute the very behavior they regulate, unlike regulative rules which regulate previously existing or independently existing forms of behaviorThe Logical Structure of Human Civilization (John Searle)
- Getting a majority of votes in the electoral college counts as being president-elect, and being sworn in by the chief justice of the supreme court counts as becoming president of the united states—these are examples of constitutive rules creating new institutional statuses.The Logical Structure of Human Civilization (John Searle)
- Civilization is built through repeated application of constitutive rules in a system where they iterate upward indefinitely—X counts as Y, and Y counts as Z, and so on—creating increasingly complex institutional structuresThe Logical Structure of Human Civilization (John Searle)
- There is an interesting asymmetry between how constitutive rules operate in language versus non-linguistic institutional facts: when you make a statement in language, no powers arise beyond the semantic powers of the language itself, but when you create non-linguistic institutional facts, the powers go beyond languageThe Logical Structure of Human Civilization (John Searle)