coarse-graining
Grouping microscopic states into macroscopic categories (macrostates), which is the choice that defines entropy for a system.
As defined in ms_ama_november_2025
Other definitions
The process of simplifying a complex system by ignoring small-scale details and focusing on aggregate or large-scale behavior; necessary for cognition and action in highly complex systems
CHATGPT won't ever be the same again after this
Where it comes up · 30
- 168 | Anil Seth on Emergence, Information, and Consciousness7 claims
- 67 | Kate Jeffery on Entropy, Complexity, and Evolution3 claims
- AMA | August 20253 claims
- AMA | December 20213 claims
- AMA | June 20223 claims
- AMA | October 20223 claims
- Mindscape Ask Me Anything, Sean Carroll | July 20263 claims
- 334 | Daniel Whiteson on the Physics of and by Aliens2 claims
and 22 more
Most important claims · 10 of 61Search all claims for “coarse-graining” →
- Causality and determinism are different: determinism (knowing the state at one time lets you calculate any other time) holds at the reversible micro-level where there is no arrow of time, so one should never use causal language there; causality—where causes precede effects—is a strictly macroscopic, time-directed phenomenon that emerges through coarse-graining and entropy, and explaining why it appears at the macro level is an open problem involving physics, philosophy, and computer science.AMA | September 2021
- While quantities like temperature, pressure, and density are loosely averages of microscopic properties, the predictive power of macroscopic descriptions is not fully explained by the easy composability of expected values; it depends on additional structure—such as equilibration and the suppression of fluctuations in large systems—so the success of thermodynamics is not merely the fact that averages are easy to reason about.AMA | April 2026
- The observed increase of entropy arises from how we coarse-grain phase space over time; without any coarse-graining, Liouville's theorem implies phase-space volume is conserved and there would be no entropy increase—raising the parallel question of whether complexity too would be constant or zero absent coarse-graining.AMA | August 2025
- Renormalization group and coarse-graining methods applied to emergent complex systems like neural networks, social science, and economics share the core idea of systematically averaging over fine-grained detail to find scale-invariant behavior, but differ from the renormalization used in fundamental physics like QED in that the latter addresses ultraviolet divergences in a fundamental field theory rather than identifying criticality in an emergent system.AMA | March 2023
- Entropy is not a relational phenomenon; for a given system with a given coarse-graining, entropy is simply high or low, full stop. What it requires is a coarse-graining — a chosen way of grouping microstates into indistinguishable macrostates — which essentially everyone agrees on but which we nonetheless must choose; once chosen, entropy is just a calculable number not related to anything else.AMA | October 2022
- Even though Gödel's incompleteness, computational irreducibility, and undecidability make perfect bottom-up simulation of emergent behavior in agent-based networks mathematically impossible, macroscopic coarse-graining remains tractable and successful—even far from equilibrium—because robust statistical regularities and effective descriptions emerge that are largely insensitive to microscopic detail, giving a thermodynamic rather than computational justification for higher-level predictability.AMA | April 2026
- Entropy is not fundamentally dependent on intelligence; while defining a coarse-graining requires choosing which microstates to group into macrostates, once that coarse-graining is specified the entropy becomes an objective matter of fact about the system, independent of whether any intelligent observer exists.AMA | August 2025
- The Second Law of Thermodynamics is universal and objective yet rests on entropy defined via human-chosen macrostates (e.g. 'racked' vs 'scattered' billiard balls), raising the puzzle of how a law of the universe can be grounded in what appears to be a subjective, artificial notion of order.AMA | September 2025
- There is a kind of complexity that is observer-dependent because it involves coarse-graining; even the well-defined concept of entropy is observer-dependent in this sense — Laplace's demon, seeing every microstate, would never need entropy and would see no arrow of time, just different states at different moments. So a coarse-graining observer thinks about complexity differently than a hypothetical (physically implausible) observer who sees every microstate.AMA | October 2022
- In the Barnett-Seth approach, a candidate weakly emergent macroscopic variable must be dynamically independent from its microscopic underpinnings, meaning that knowing what is going on at the microscopic level does not help you predict the macroscopic variable's evolution; this enables data-driven discovery of candidate emergent coarse-grainings even when the emergent property does not visibly leap out to an observer.168 | Anil Seth on Emergence, Information, and Consciousness