coarse graining
Grouping many detailed microscopic states into broader macroscopic categories, used to define entropy as the count of microstates per macrostate.
As defined in AMA | October 2024
Where it comes up · 7
- 295 | Solo: Emergence and Layers of Reality4 claims
- 196 | Judea Pearl on Cause and Effect2 claims
- 151 | Jordan Ellenberg on the Mathematics of Political Boundaries1 claim
- 158 | David Wallace on the Arrow of Time1 claim
- AMA | March 20221 claim
- AMA | May 20211 claim
- AMA | October 20241 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 11Search all claims for “coarse graining” →
- Entropy is defined as the logarithm of the number of microstates compatible with a given macrostate, which requires a coarse-graining choice of which macroscopic variables matter, making the numerical value partly dependent on that choice, yet the thermodynamic arrow of time still works because of the empirically low-entropy past.AMA | October 2024
- Without the past hypothesis (that the early universe had very low entropy), retrodicting from the current macrostate alone would predict the past to look exactly like the future with macroscopic momenta reversed — meaning entropy would increase toward the past, radiation would converge on the sun rather than radiate away, and the asymmetry between past and future would vanish.AMA | March 2022
- Whether the entropy of a physical system is subjective or objective is 'yes' because the word has multiple definitions: the Gibbs/ignorance entropy from a probability distribution over microstates is fully subjective; the von Neumann entanglement entropy of a quantum subsystem is fully objective; and the Boltzmann entropy is objective given a coarse-graining but the choice of coarse-graining is subjective.AMA | May 2021
- From a probability distribution over the macroscopic state of the world plus the laws of physics one can predict the future distribution, but one cannot retrodict the past without an extra assumption—the low-entropy boundary condition near the Big Bang—and this asymmetry is what breaks the symmetry between past and future.196 | Judea Pearl on Cause and Effect
- Pearl argues that the perceived low entropy of the racked billiard triangle is not objective but a subjective artifact of language: we have a single name for the orderly triangle but no name for the dispersed state a moment later, and thermodynamic entropy increase is really the natural escape from a narrow region of phase space to a wider one, not a progression from order to disorder.196 | Judea Pearl on Cause and Effect
- Emergence is demonstrated by the fact that you can predict the trajectory of a crumpled ball of paper without knowing the microscopic state of its atoms, because relatively few pieces of macroscopic information (center of mass, environment) suffice; crucially we not only can throw away microscopic information but know exactly which information to discard.295 | Solo: Emergence and Layers of Reality
- Fluid dynamics emerges from atomic/kinetic theory by dividing space into small cells and replacing the many atoms in each cell with a few collective variables—density, pressure, velocity, temperature—which greatly decreases information; this is a richer example than planets because the higher-level emergent description speaks a fundamentally different language (fluids) than the lower-level (particles).295 | Solo: Emergence and Layers of Reality
- Emergence is formally defined as a relationship between a micro and macro theory each with states and Markovian evolution laws, connected by a many-to-one coarse-graining 'emergence map'; it requires that the diagram commutes—evolving the microstate then mapping to a macrostate yields the same result as mapping first then evolving—so the macro theory has sensible self-contained dynamics despite discarding information.295 | Solo: Emergence and Layers of Reality
- Emergent non-locality only becomes relevant when coarse-graining is so heavy that the speed of light is not a practical limitation; if both the lower and higher level theories are still fairly low level (e.g. standard model to superconductor electrons), the speed of light remains a fundamental limit and no emergent non-locality appears.295 | Solo: Emergence and Layers of Reality
- The defensible notion of a macro state is not defined by our perceptual limitations but as a level of description at which you get a robust, autonomous, self-contained dynamical story — you can reliably predict the future coarse-grained state from the present coarse-grained state — which is why statistical mechanics works for systems no one cares to observe in detail, including galaxies.158 | David Wallace on the Arrow of Time