climate sensitivity
The amount of global warming expected from a doubling of atmospheric CO2, estimated as a range due to deep uncertainty.
As defined in John Christy and Kerry Emanuel on Climate Change
Where it comes up · 8
- Matt Ridley on Climate Change5 claims
- Martin Weitzman on Climate Change4 claims
- 65 | Michael Mann on Why Our Climate Is Changing and How We Know3 claims
- John Christy and Kerry Emanuel on Climate Change2 claims
- Robert Pindyck on Climate Change1 claim
- Judith Curry on Climate Change1 claim
- 208 - Existential Risk1 claim
- 151 - Will We Destroy The Future1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 18Search all claims for “climate sensitivity” →
- Pre-industrial greenhouse gas concentrations were about 280 parts per million and had hardly ever exceeded that in 800,000 years (known from arctic ice cores); we are now at about 440 ppm CO2-equivalent, a 50% increase over the multi-million-year high, and reaching 700 ppm would represent CO2 increases not seen for at least 50 million years.Martin Weitzman on Climate Change
- A third type of vulnerability arises when a large number of weak actors each face incentives to take individually negligible actions that aggregate into civilizational damage; global warming illustrates this, and counterfactually a higher climate sensitivity (e.g. 50 degrees instead of 3) or more expensive alternatives would have turned fossil fuels into a black ball.151 - Will We Destroy The Future
- The key climate uncertainty is magnitude: we do not know how much a doubling of greenhouse gas concentration will raise temperature (it could be 1-2°C or 5°C), nor how severely a 3-4°C rise would harm the economy and welfare, nor how successfully humanity could adapt through new crops, geographic shifts in agriculture, or disease responses — we know it's bad, we don't know how bad.Robert Pindyck on Climate Change
- Climate sensitivity—the eventual temperature change from a doubling of CO2—is a probability distribution that has stayed between 1.5 and 4.5 degrees Centigrade for 35 years; with a doubling of CO2 there is roughly a 10% chance of exceeding 4.5 degrees and a 3% chance of exceeding 6 degrees, and at 700 ppm the chance of exceeding 6 degrees rises to about 10%. These probabilities are low but not low enough to ignore.Martin Weitzman on Climate Change
- Although there has been vastly more climate research, models, and observations over 35 years, the uncertainty range for climate sensitivity has not narrowed because as old uncertainties are resolved, new forms of uncertainty (like cloud formation and unpredicted arctic ice melt) keep emerging.Martin Weitzman on Climate Change
- Fourteen peer-reviewed papers based on observational data, available to the IPCC for its 2013-2014 reports, all pointed to much lower climate sensitivity than previously assumed; the IPCC narrowed its range and declined to give a best estimate (previously 3 degrees), yet impact models worldwide still assume 3 degrees, while most scientists working on it now accept sensitivity is in the 1-2 degree range.Matt Ridley on Climate Change
- The fat tail in the climate sensitivity distribution (the small-but-significant chance of very large warming) that underlies Weitzman's precautionary argument has gotten much thinner with updated data, partly because a distorted graph in the 2007 IPCC AR4 report (identified by Nick Lewis) exaggerated the tail; correcting it and incorporating the latest observational papers yields much thinner tails, so a claimed 10% chance of 6 degrees becomes much less than 1%.Matt Ridley on Climate Change
- It is widely agreed, including by the IPCC, that doubling the level of CO2 in the atmosphere produces only about 1 degree of warming directly; the higher 3-degree sensitivity figure comes entirely from a modeled amplifying feedback, mainly water vapor, and the curved relationship means each doubling (300 to 600, 800 to 1600) yields the same ~1 degree.Matt Ridley on Climate Change
- The observed rate of warming over the past 20-50 years (a little more than 0.1 degree per decade) has been much slower than IPCC climate models predicted; the IPCC attributes only about a third of a degree over 50 years to human activity, which is extremely hard to measure accurately, and surface temperatures show faster warming than satellites, suggesting urban heat island contamination.Matt Ridley on Climate Change
- Over the next 100 years, if no radical action slows CO2 accumulation, the temperature would rise between 2.5 and 9 degrees Fahrenheit for a doubling or more of CO2—a wide range that essentially confesses deep uncertainty; the low end (2.5°F) is not worrisome, the middle range brings adaptable problems, and the high end could be catastrophic.John Christy and Kerry Emanuel on Climate Change