cliff effect
A sharp loss of benefits that occurs when income rises just past an eligibility cutoff, creating a strong disincentive to earn more.
As defined in Michael Munger on the Basic Income Guarantee
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “cliff effect” →
- A second reason for giving BIG to everyone rather than only the poor is that a means-tested benefit (e.g., everyone under $25,000 gets $25,000) creates a severe cliff problem where someone earning $27,000 works a huge amount to net only $2,000; though Roberts notes this could be smoothed by gradually phasing out the benefit up to ~$100,000 rather than paying everyone.Michael Munger on the Basic Income Guarantee
- The current welfare system imposes an effective marginal tax rate well over 100% on the very poor, because earning income or getting married causes loss of stacked benefits (Section 8 housing, child support, unemployment, heat subsidies) that exceeds the new earnings; a BIG, being a negative head tax that is not lost as income rises, would reduce that marginal rate to near zero and induce more poor people to work.Michael Munger on the Basic Income Guarantee
- Many welfare programs (food stamps, lunch programs) deliberately transfer money to people above the poverty line because benefits must be phased out slowly as income rises to avoid cliff effects; therefore programs that appear 'ineffective' at targeting the poor are designed that way for the reasonable purpose of not discouraging work, and the claim that consolidating into BIG will save money by only helping the poor is bad accounting.Michael Munger on the Basic Income Guarantee
- Munger is less concerned about the income effect of BIG (people working less because they have money) than about the substitution effect of the current system, which encourages the very poor to substitute toward leisure because of cliff effects and benefit cutoffs; he believes most poor people want to work and the main barrier is the disincentive structure, not laziness.Michael Munger on the Basic Income Guarantee