civilization/barbarism axis
The Conservative moral framing in which the good is accumulated civilized values that have stood the test of time, and the bad is barbarians who strike against those values.
As defined in Arnold Kling on the Three Languages of Politics
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “civilization/barbarism axis” →
- Political ideologies organize good and bad along three distinct axes: Progressives use oppressor/oppressed (good = aligning against oppression), Conservatives use civilization/barbarism (good = accumulated civilized values that pass the test of time), and Libertarians use freedom/coercion (good = free individual choice, bad = government coercion at gunpoint).Arnold Kling on the Three Languages of Politics
- The three axes let one detect when an economist has left the economic paradigm: a Progressive economist writing in oppressor/oppressed terms (unless a literal Marxist) or a Conservative economist writing in civilization/barbarism terms has 'taken off their economic clothes,' and Libertarians slip into their freedom/coercion axis more often than anyone because economics so often touches government intervention.Arnold Kling on the Three Languages of Politics
- On immigration, Progressives see immigrants as an oppressed group and hostile natives as oppressors (with a caveat about low-skilled American workers also being oppressed); Conservatives see a defined border as a civilized value that illegal crossing violates; and Libertarians see borders as government coercion and favor open borders.Arnold Kling on the Three Languages of Politics
- Reactions to the Boston Marathon bombing illustrate the three axes: the Weekly Standard titled its piece 'Civilization and Barbarism'; a Slate column hoped the bomber was a white male (an oppressor-class figure); Obama's 'self-radicalizing terrorism' framing avoided the civilization/barbarism framing; and Libertarians focused on the police-state lockdown.Arnold Kling on the Three Languages of Politics