civilization versus barbarism
The conservative moral axis that interprets political conflicts as defending civilization against barbarism.
As defined in Misinformation and the Three Languages of Politics (with Arnold Kling)
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 3 of 3Search all claims for “civilization versus barbarism” →
- Political tribes reason along three different moral axes that they each claim ownership of: conservatives use civilization-versus-barbarism and denounce opponents as barbaric; progressives use oppressor-versus-oppressed and demonize opponents as oppressors; libertarians use liberty-versus-coercion and accuse opponents of wanting to coerce—so each tribe demonizes the others using its own framing.Misinformation and the Three Languages of Politics (with Arnold Kling)
- Although Kling thought the Three Languages model was deteriorating before October 7th, the reactions to the Hamas attack revived it: progressives took anti-Israel, pro-Hamas stances using oppressor/oppressed language (Israel inherently the oppressor regardless of what Hamas did), while conservatives immediately invoked civilization-versus-barbarism, a framing Netanyahu used within the first minute of his address to Congress.Misinformation and the Three Languages of Politics (with Arnold Kling)
- When people perceive an existential threat, the operative moral axis shifts: Jews on the left who were sympathetic to the oppressor/oppressed story become more likely to use the civilization-versus-barbarism axis when they believe their children's lives are at risk—as the saying goes, knowing one will be hanged in a fortnight concentrates the mind wonderfully.Misinformation and the Three Languages of Politics (with Arnold Kling)