chartalism
The view that money derives value from the state's demand that taxes be paid in it; described implicitly via empires forcing tax payment in their currency.
As defined in Yuval Harari on Sapiens
Where it comes up · 2
- Zach Carter3 claims
- Yuval Harari on Sapiens2 claims
Most important claims · 5 of 5Search all claims for “chartalism” →
- Money's acceptability is better described as expectation than pure trust—I accept a dollar because I expect others to accept it—and that confidence is fragile and not blind: if a sovereign inflates the currency, trust collapses quickly, and acceptance is reinforced concretely because the government takes taxes in that currency.Yuval Harari on Sapiens
- Keynes effectively repudiated his Treatise on Money, since there would have been no need for The General Theory if the Treatise had been right; the Treatise's ad hoc, knotted justification for public works as a one-time necessity reflects Keynes tying himself in knots to justify a policy preference, though its discussion of chartalism and the rise of capitalism is essential to ideas later developed in The General Theory.Zach Carter
- European empires built trust in valueless paper money among colonized African populations by demanding that taxes be paid in that money and using violence against non-compliers, creating an initial need for the currency that established its acceptance.Yuval Harari on Sapiens
- If money is taken to be a creature of the state rather than of markets, then the idea of the market functioning independently of government becomes much blurrier and the state becomes the thing that creates and guides markets, which opens up a much broader realm for government intervention.Zach Carter
- Cryptocurrency does not refute Knapp's State Theory of Money; because so much cryptocurrency use is illegal, nongovernmental, and a vehicle for fraud, the experience actually points toward the conclusion that money needs political management to have real, durable meaning rather than being a sustainable purely market-based phenomenon.Zach Carter