challenge trials
Clinical trials in which healthy volunteers are deliberately exposed to a pathogen after vaccination to measure efficacy quickly, rather than waiting for natural exposure.
As defined in John Cochrane on the Pandemic
Where it comes up · 5
- 204 - A Conversation With Jonathan Haidt2 claims
- John Cochrane on the Pandemic1 claim
- 270 - What Have We Learned From The Pandemic1 claim
- 271 - Earning To Give1 claim
- 290 - What Went Wrong1 claim
Most important claims · 6 of 6Search all claims for “challenge trials” →
- Because most people in standard vaccine trials are careful and few get exposed, requiring researchers to wait for tiny numbers of natural infections makes trials slow; allowing healthy young volunteers to deliberately expose themselves in challenge trials would have produced better data far more quickly, but the FDA refused on ethical grounds.John Cochrane on the Pandemic
- Moderna designed its mRNA COVID vaccine in two days in January 2020 from the virus's genetic code, two months before COVID hit the US, but the risk-management system prohibited human challenge trials (which would have visibly infected volunteers); as a result the vaccine wasn't rolled out until a year later, and in the counterfactual roughly 300,000 people who died would have been better off — a textbook seen-versus-unseen failure.290 - What Went Wrong
- Scientists' concern in 2020 was not against rushing vaccines into arms but against implementing an unsafe speedy-development process; the approval happening just after the election was coincidence, not conspiracy, since the trials were stopped early because the vaccine was so obviously effective.270 - What Have We Learned From The Pandemic
- A genuine success of COVID was the new superpower of being able to make an mRNA vaccine in 24 hours, but it still took a year from COVID appearing to people getting vaccinated, including eight months after having the vaccine to push it through the approval process—eight months when people were dying—which approved challenge trials could speed up next time.271 - Earning To Give
- Many claims presented as established facts about the virus — such as 'don't wear masks' — turned out to be wrong or unsupported, so claims about how long a vaccine will take, given roughly a hundred vaccines in development and the move toward challenge trials, should be actively questioned rather than accepted as settled.204 - A Conversation With Jonathan Haidt
- Given that the death rate was unknown and could have been 3-6 percent and doctors lacked masks, the early lockdowns were not genuinely disputable; but after the first wave passed at enormous economic and personal cost, alternative approaches such as the Sweden model became at least reasonable to debate.204 - A Conversation With Jonathan Haidt