censorship
The suppression or blocking of ideas or speech by an authority rather than allowing them to compete openly.
As defined in Misinformation and the Three Languages of Politics (with Arnold Kling)
Where it comes up · 3
- What Happened to the Republican Party?: A Conversation with Bret Stephens (Episode #329)5 claims
- Misinformation and the Three Languages of Politics (with Arnold Kling)4 claims
- 163 - Ricky Gervais1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 10Search all claims for “censorship” →
- Free speech means you can say what you want and others can criticize you back, but it does not mean freedom from criticism or consequences; private employers declining to hire someone over their speech is not censorship because it is not government intervention.163 - Ricky Gervais
- Saying 'these ideas should be censored' in the passive voice conceals the problem; restated in the active voice—'Person A should be entitled to censor person B'—it becomes clear you are granting someone power to suppress ideas, which is preferable to correct only through more speech and competing ideas.Misinformation and the Three Languages of Politics (with Arnold Kling)
- One should trust people who seek the truth and distrust those who claim to have found it, because people who claim certainty are the most dangerous; the fight against misinformation is problematic precisely because censors implicitly claim to have found truth definitively enough to suppress competing beliefs.Misinformation and the Three Languages of Politics (with Arnold Kling)
- Granting any single person, board, or AI the authority to decide what is true and censor the rest fails for two reasons paralleling the case against industrial-policy autocrats: they are not wise enough to reliably identify truth, and they are corruptible—susceptible to acting in their own or bribed interests rather than the core mission.Misinformation and the Three Languages of Politics (with Arnold Kling)
- When institutions and authorities suppress or censor claims they judge to be false or harmful, they often inadvertently amplify those claims by creating a narrative of persecution and martyrdom, making censored figures appear more credible and trustworthy to those skeptical of institutional authority.What Happened to the Republican Party?: A Conversation with Bret Stephens (Episode #329)
- The misinformation problem is often overstated, and the real issue is institutional suppression of speech; people have always believed and circulated false claims throughout history, and a free society necessarily tolerates considerable falsehood, so the focus should be on institutional behavior rather than on eliminating misinformation.What Happened to the Republican Party?: A Conversation with Bret Stephens (Episode #329)
- Twitter's blocking of the New York Post's account when it released its Hunter Biden article was a more 'heavy-handed and harder to defend' form of censorship than editorial decisions not to lead with the story, and it produced the Streisand Effect of attracting more attentionWhat Happened to the Republican Party?: A Conversation with Bret Stephens (Episode #329)
- Even views one finds abhorrent and false, such as Holocaust denial, should be allowed to be argued because the value lies in protecting the truth-seeking process itself; shutting down that process does not justify a desired outcome.Misinformation and the Three Languages of Politics (with Arnold Kling)
- The Wuhan virology Institute as a potential pandemic origin source was effectively banned from discussion on Facebook until it turned out to be a well-grounded hypothesis, exemplifying how censorship gatekeepers can suppress accurate informationWhat Happened to the Republican Party?: A Conversation with Bret Stephens (Episode #329)
- Sunlight (transparency and open debate) is generally the best disinfectant against misinformation, so even fringe figures like Alex Jones should be platformed and debated rather than censored, because censorship suggests institutional fear rather than confidence in the truth.What Happened to the Republican Party?: A Conversation with Bret Stephens (Episode #329)