by-right development
A legal regime in which, if a project satisfies the published rules, officials are legally obligated to issue the permit and cannot deny it through discretionary review.
As defined in Why Housing Is Artificially Expensive and What Can Be Done About It (with Bryan Caplan)
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “by-right development” →
- The preferred reform is to expand 'by-right development'—where satisfying the published rules legally obligates officials to issue the permit and they cannot be denied—by eliminating height limits, minimum lot sizes, and parking requirements (paired with demand-based street-parking pricing), and ideally moving to a system where no permit is needed and aggrieved neighbors must sue, with the difficulty of suing being a feature given the strong bias against construction.Why Housing Is Artificially Expensive and What Can Be Done About It (with Bryan Caplan)
- Building codes typically require two or three parking spots per apartment unit, which combined with chronic government underpricing of street parking forces developers to devote roughly three times the land for stores-plus-parking versus stores alone, raising the per-unit cost needed to make projects viable.Why Housing Is Artificially Expensive and What Can Be Done About It (with Bryan Caplan)
- Until around 1920 there was almost no regulation of multifamily housing—if you owned the land you could build multifamily—until a Supreme Court case likened apartments to blowing smoke onto a neighbor's lawn, after which permission became required.Why Housing Is Artificially Expensive and What Can Be Done About It (with Bryan Caplan)
- Delay functions like a cost on building: the longer it takes to get a building approved, the more it must earn in rents or sales to make the investment worthwhile, and activists exploit serial reviews (environmental, parking, traffic) and demands to redo studies so that even legally permitted projects become not worth attempting.Why Housing Is Artificially Expensive and What Can Be Done About It (with Bryan Caplan)