blameworthiness
The moral concept of the degree to which a person deserves blame for a situation or outcome.
As defined in Bryan Caplan
Where it comes up · 2
Most important claims · 3 of 3Search all claims for “blameworthiness” →
- Optimal-deterrence theory recommends raising punishments when the probability of being caught is low, but this is inherently unfair because those who are caught bear a penalty disproportionate to their blameworthiness; punishing more than is deserved carries a hidden cost of undermining the system's moral credibility, which itself reduces crime-control effectiveness.Paul Robinson on Cooperation, Punishment and the Criminal Justice System
- Empirical studies show a shared intuition about justice that cuts across all demographics and politics: when people rank-order cases by seriousness they agree to a staggering degree (a Kendall's W around .96), so disagreement only appears once a case becomes a politicized headline that short-circuits people's intuitions.Paul Robinson on Cooperation, Punishment and the Criminal Justice System
- Caplan's planned book 'Poverty — Who to Blame' will revive the neglected moral concepts of blameworthiness and desert (dismissed by consequentialists), using social science to distinguish blameworthy, non-blameworthy, and semi-blameworthy poverty — arguing the most morally urgent case is Third World poverty of people who could easily get First World jobs if it were legal, which receives far less attention than self-inflicted cases like chronic alcoholism.Bryan Caplan