black hole information problem
The puzzle of whether information that falls into a black hole is destroyed or preserved, central to reconciling quantum mechanics with gravity.
As defined in 130 | Frank Wilczek on the Present and Future of Fundamental Physics
Where it comes up · 4
- 130 | Frank Wilczek on the Present and Future of Fundamental Physics1 claim
- 242 | David Krakauer on Complexity, Agency, and Information1 claim
- 99 | Scott Aaronson on Complexity, Computation, and Quantum Gravity1 claim
- AMA | October 20211 claim
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “black hole information problem” →
- The black hole information problem is yielding intellectually coherent pictures and surprising connections to error correction and new quantum theory, but it is a very esoteric problem with no experimental system to which the ideas apply directly, the distance between the models and observable black holes is vast, and so it is unclear what it even means to solve it; it is interesting but not the pinnacle of physics.130 | Frank Wilczek on the Present and Future of Fundamental Physics
- A black hole has the largest entropy of any object of its size — it is the highest-density hard disk allowed by the laws of physics, storing about 10-to-the-69 qubits per square meter of event-horizon surface area — though it is useless for retrieval since bits emerge only as scrambled Hawking radiation over perhaps 10-to-the-70 years.99 | Scott Aaronson on Complexity, Computation, and Quantum Gravity
- Quantum fields do not generally have analytic properties; analyticity may hold in special states like the vacuum of a quantum field theory but not in an arbitrary state, so once you have a black hole with information dumped into it there is no reason a function's behavior in one region tells you its behavior elsewhere, defeating the proposed analytic-continuation resolution of the black hole information puzzle.AMA | October 2021
- The claim that no major progress has occurred in fundamental theoretical physics since 1980 is adjacent to a true statement but not actually true: while no new model correctly mapping onto reality has emerged beyond the standard model, general relativity, and Big Bang theory, there have been enormous insights into those theories and speculative models—the black hole information problem alone has been a font of ideas like holography.242 | David Krakauer on Complexity, Agency, and Information