black hole information paradox
The puzzle, raised by Hawking, that combining general relativity with quantum field theory implies that information about how a black hole formed is lost when it evaporates, in apparent violation of quantum mechanics.
As defined in 349 | Daniel Harlow on What Quantum Gravity Teaches Us About Quantum Mechanics
Other definitions
A fundamental inconsistency: Hawking radiation from black holes appears irreversible and information-destroying, conflicting with quantum mechanics' reversibility, creating an apparent contradiction between the two theories
Existential physics: answering life's biggest questions - with Sabine Hossenfelder
Where it comes up · 8
- 218 | Raphael Bousso on Black Holes and the Holographic Universe3 claims
- AMA | July 20212 claims
- Ask Me Anything | October 20262 claims
- Sabine Hossenfelder on Physics, Reality, and Lost in Math1 claim
- Existential physics: answering life's biggest questions - with Sabine Hossenfelder1 claim
- 349 | Daniel Harlow on What Quantum Gravity Teaches Us About Quantum Mechanics1 claim
- AMA | November 20221 claim
- Mindscape Ask Me Anything, Sean Carroll | August 20261 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 12Search all claims for “black hole information paradox” →
- What we know about the fundamental laws of nature implies that information cannot get lost—black holes are the only known thing that could really destroy information, and assuming that black-hole information paradox is resolved so they can't, then the information about everything that makes you who you are must persist forever, just possibly in a form no longer recognizable as you.Sabine Hossenfelder on Physics, Reality, and Lost in Math
- Hawking showed that combining general relativity with quantum field theory at weak gravitational coupling leads to a paradox: a black hole behaves as if it has a finite number of degrees of freedom (entropy proportional to horizon area divided by Newton's constant) and radiates thermally, yet you can fit arbitrarily much stuff inside it, so when it evaporates the information about how it was created appears to vanish.349 | Daniel Harlow on What Quantum Gravity Teaches Us About Quantum Mechanics
- Information is treated as a conserved quantity like angular momentum or energy, and the asker wants to know why physicists bristle at the idea that information falling into a black hole is destroyed.Mindscape Ask Me Anything, Sean Carroll | August 2026
- Black holes from stellar collapse only asymptotically approach an event horizon from an outside view, while Hawking radiation comes from outside the horizon and may evaporate the hole in finite time, possibly before the horizon forms, which would seem to dissolve the information paradox.Ask Me Anything | October 2026
- Astrophysical black holes observed in the cosmos have extremely low temperatures and extremely long evaporation timescales (hundreds of billions of years), and currently they don't evaporate at all because the cosmic microwave background is hotter than them, so the black hole information paradox cannot be experimentally tested with existing observational astronomy.Existential physics: answering life's biggest questions - with Sabine Hossenfelder
- There is a genuine conflict—the firewall paradox, a sharpened black hole information paradox—between the outside observer's view (information comes out, so it must be stored on the horizon like a membrane) and general relativity's insistence that an infalling observer crosses the horizon and finds nothing special; physicists care about both quantum mechanics and gravity, and there is currently no resolution that fully preserves both principles.218 | Raphael Bousso on Black Holes and the Holographic Universe
- Contrary to the assumption that black holes are exactly where general relativity and quantum field theory break down, both should be trustworthy near a large black hole's event horizon, because GR fails only where curvature blows up (the singularity, not the horizon, where curvature can be small) and QFT is trustworthy near the vacuum with few particles (which holds near the horizon); the genuine puzzle is that both being trustworthy there jointly produces the information loss paradox, suggesting one (probably QFT, via some subtle non-locality) is wrong near the horizon.AMA | July 2021
- Locality—the idea that things interact when they bump into each other at the same point in space and fields react only at and immediately near where they are poked—is fundamental to quantum field theory like the Standard Model, but quantizing fields around a black hole leads to Hawking radiation and the information loss puzzle, suggesting something non-local about the black hole.218 | Raphael Bousso on Black Holes and the Holographic Universe
- Destroying information, whether in dementia, burning a book, or erasing a hard drive, changes the nature of reality but does not destroy actual reality, since momentum and energy remain conserved, so the concern about black holes destroying information is misplaced.Ask Me Anything | October 2026
- The Reeh-Schlieder theorem establishes that any two regions of the quantum vacuum share some entanglement and that projecting on one region can in principle turn the rest of the universe's wave function into nearly anything — but this does not resolve the black hole information paradox, because (like the impossibility of choosing your spin outcome to enable superluminal signaling) you cannot force or choose these projections, the relevant operations are extraordinarily unlikely, and mere existence of entanglement across the horizon is not enough to get the information out.AMA | July 2021