benevolent slavery
The claim that slavery was a paternalistic arrangement that raised slaves' material well-being, used historically to justify the institution; refuted by liberals on consent rather than income grounds.
As defined in Colonialism, Slavery, and Foreign Aid (with William Easterly)
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 1 of 1Search all claims for “benevolent slavery” →
- The effective argument that ended slavery was not disputing whether slaves' material consumption rose (which thinkers from Adam Smith to Robert Fogel grant may have been higher than for those in Africa or the white working class), but the moral argument from consent: if slavery were so benevolent, why was so much force needed to impose it, why did slaves run away, and why--as Lincoln noted--did slave owners want it only for others and never for themselves?Colonialism, Slavery, and Foreign Aid (with William Easterly)