benevolent autocrat
The argument that a dictator using force is a good thing if they raise GDP or reduce poverty rates; the modern analogue of the benevolent-slavery and colonial-development justifications.
As defined in Colonialism, Slavery, and Foreign Aid (with William Easterly)
Where it comes up · 2
- William Easterly on Benevolent Autocrats and Growth 05/30/20116 claims
- Colonialism, Slavery, and Foreign Aid (with William Easterly)1 claim
Most important claims · 7 of 7Search all claims for “benevolent autocrat” →
- If a leader's growth fluctuates wildly during their term, it is unjustified to attribute the outcomes to that leader; the 'they start stupid and then get smart' story to explain swings is circular reasoning, since the explanation is adjusted to whatever the outcome was.William Easterly on Benevolent Autocrats and Growth 05/30/2011
- It is impossible to do value-free development analysis: when an expert concentrates only on measurable poverty because dignity, self-respect, and agency cannot be measured, they are implicitly making a value judgment that those non-material needs do not matter for the people in question, and they should at least admit they are making that judgment rather than presenting it as objective.Colonialism, Slavery, and Foreign Aid (with William Easterly)
- Since economists struggle to systematically understand what causes growth, a benevolent autocrat would have difficulty implementing growth intentionally.William Easterly on Benevolent Autocrats and Growth 05/30/2011
- The key unresolved question is not whether autocracies have high variance but whether that variance can be credibly attributed to good and bad leaders; the paper argues it cannot.William Easterly on Benevolent Autocrats and Growth 05/30/2011
- Thomas Friedman's praise of one-party autocracy led by enlightened leaders rests on an assumption that autocrats can follow the advice of intellectual elites like himself, which is a fantasy of unconstrained rulers.William Easterly on Benevolent Autocrats and Growth 05/30/2011
- A benevolent autocrat is any leader of a non-democratic society who gets credit for high economic growth, such as Lee Kuan Yew for Singapore's miracle or Park Chung-hee for South Korea's growth.William Easterly on Benevolent Autocrats and Growth 05/30/2011
- Easterly began the paper willing to give the benevolent autocrat hypothesis a fair shake and finished convinced there is no theory or evidence supporting benevolent autocrats.William Easterly on Benevolent Autocrats and Growth 05/30/2011